After years, notarytool now cannot find Keychain item

I’m not sure what’s going on here, but the best path forward is to do what the error says: Run store-credentials to create a new profile. Given it a different name so it doesn’t stomp on your existing profile.

That’ll tell you one of two things:

• If the new profile also fails then something quite weird is going on.

• If the new profile works then there’s likely some minor difference in the keychain items that’s causing this. You could then diff the two to see what’s what. Or just ignore this oddity and switch to using the new profile.

Share and Enjoy
—
Quinn “The Eskimo!” @ Developer Technical Support @ Apple
let myEmail = "eskimo" + "1" + "@" + "apple.com"

Thank you, Quinn. I attempted to run the store-credentials but got a confused. It asked me for the Path to App Store Connect API private key. I didn't have one of those. So I attempted to create a new key here:

https://developer.apple.com/account/resources/authkeys/

To make a long story short, this led me down the wrong keygen rabbit hole. After some more poking around I found this page:

https://appstoreconnect.apple.com/access/integrations/api

Success. store-credentials accepted the key which I created there, and created a new keychain item which works with notarytool submit. Problem solved.

Except to understand why. As you can see from my screenshot, the old keychain item wrapped a password (which was 19 characters), with a name. The new keychain item is much more complex. Its Name is com.apple.gke.notary.tool, Account is le.gke.notary.tool.saved-creds.MyName and its Where is appStoreConnect. Most intriguingly, when I click Show password, and enter the keychain password, nothing happens.

So maybe the problem was that the current version of notarytool no longer accepts my old-style simple password keychain item. It now requires this fancy item which based on a private key that Keychain Access can't show me. Is that more or less what happened?

Is that more or less what happened?

There are two ways for notarytool to authenticate with the notary service:

• App-specific password

• App Store Connect API key

Both of these are supported. Personally, I tend to prefer the latter, because it’s easier to understand, but app-specific passwords should continue to work.

So, the significant difference between your old and new profile is expected because the old one uses an app-specific password and the new one use an API key.

However, that doesn’t explain why notarytool was unnable to use the old one. If you want to dig into that, you could run the the store-credentials process again and this time skip the API key option. notarytool will then prompt you for your Apple ID and app-specific password. Once you get that working you can then diff the two profiles in the keychain to see what’s different.

Or just ignore this oddity and move on with your life. After all, authenticating with an API key is a good option.

Share and Enjoy
—
Quinn “The Eskimo!” @ Developer Technical Support @ Apple
let myEmail = "eskimo" + "1" + "@" + "apple.com"

I'm moving on, Quinn. Thank you for the explanation.