Sign in with Apple fails with "Cannot Connect" on first sign-up for one app only (other apps on the same team work)

Sign in with Apple fails for one of our iOS apps (bundle ID kr.certlab.app) on the very first sign-up, while other apps from the same developer team work on the same device.

Steps

  1. Tap "Sign in with Apple" in the app (ASAuthorizationAppleIDProvider, scopes: fullName, email).
  2. The Apple sheet appears with name and "Share My Email / Hide My Email".
  3. Tap "Continue".
  4. Alert: "Cannot Connect — Make sure you are connected to Wi-Fi or cellular network." The request fails with ASAuthorizationError (unknown).

The app never appears under Settings > Apple Account > Sign-In & Security > Sign in with Apple, so no link is created.

Same iPhone, same Wi-Fi, same Apple Account:

  • Works: four other apps from the same team (including a brand-new first-time sign-up). They use the same Flutter code (sign_in_with_apple) and the same entitlement.
  • Fails: kr.certlab.app only. TestFlight builds 4, 5, 7 and 8 all fail. It has never worked since the first build.

What we checked

  • App ID kr.certlab.app has Sign in with Apple enabled as a primary App ID (same setting as the working apps).
  • The App Store provisioning profile and the app's entitlements contain com.apple.developer.applesignin = Default.
  • We removed and re-added the capability, created a new provisioning profile and uploaded a new build. Same result.
  • No Services IDs exist on the team, so there is no web configuration that could conflict.
  • Another app of ours showed the same alert once today and worked on the second try. kr.certlab.app fails every time.

Has anyone seen Sign in with Apple fail like this for a single App ID? Is there anything on the App ID or App Store Connect side that can block the first consent? Apple Developer Support case: 30000016304083 / Feedback: FB25591915

Thank you.