xcframework does not contain internal frameworks

Like https://forums.developer.apple.com/message/389765#389765, I am trying to create an xcframework file for a few third party libraries I'm using. Following the instructions from https://appspector.com/blog/xcframeworks, I



1. Create platform-specific framework files:

# Archive for device
xcodebuild archive -scheme TestFramework -destination="iOS" -archivePath /tmp/xcf/ios.xcarchive -derivedDataPath /tmp/iphoneos -sdk iphoneos SKIP_INSTALL=NO BUILD_LIBRARIES_FOR_DISTRIBUTION=YES


# Archive for simulator
xcodebuild archive -scheme TestFramework -destination="iOS Simulator" -archivePath /tmp/xcf/iossimulator.xcarchive -derivedDataPath /tmp/iphoneos -sdk iphonesimulator SKIP_INSTALL=NO BUILD_LIBRARIES_FOR_DISTRIBUTION=YES


At this point, I've gotten two frameworks with swiftmodule files; everything looks good. The frameworks do *not* come with swiftinterface

files, but I think that is alright as these are objc projects. Then, I



2. Combine the individual frameworks to form a single xcframework file:

# Build xcframework with two archives
xcodebuild -create-xcframework -framework /tmp/xcf/ios.xcarchive/Products/Library/Frameworks/TestFramework.framework -framework /tmp/xcf/iossimulator.xcarchive/Products/Library/Frameworks/TestFramework.framework -output /tmp/xcf/TestFramework.xcframework


Here, xcodebuild doesn't fail, but it emits a curious error:

No 'swiftinterface' files found within '/Users/user/git/ReactiveObjC/output/xcf/ios.xcarchive/Products/Products/Library/TestFramework.framework/Modules/TestFramework.swiftmodule'.


Crucially, the xcframework package does not contain the individual frameworks or folders specified in the Info.plist file. Obviously, when I try to link to the xcframework in this state, I get a bunch of "missing symbols" linker errors.



Why is this? What must I do to get xcodebuild to create the xcframework completely?



NB: Manually creating the folders seems to work for now, but this feels wrong and is brittle – Apple can change the way xcodebuild works anytime.

Up vote post of pkoggg2 Down vote post of pkoggg2
19k views
Posted by
pkoggg2
Reply
Add a Comment

Accepted Reply

Turns out that adding BUILD_LIBRARY_FOR_DISTRIBUTION = YES to the end of the xcodebuild command was not enough / not working to produce a framework with the required swiftinterface files. I had to go in the settings for the actual project and manually set BUILD_LIBRARY_FOR_DISTRIBUTION to YES, like this answer suggests, then I was able to get frameworks with the swiftinterface files. After I got the frameworks with the swiftinterface files, I was then able to create the xcframework file using xcodebuild without any problems.

Posted by
pkoggg2
Up vote reply of pkoggg2 Down vote reply of pkoggg2
Post marked as solved

  • I work this solution; I opened the xcode and I searched BUILD_LIBRARY_FOR_DISTRIBUTION in Buid setings and changed to "YES" I deleted platform-specific and rebiuld again

    —
    annunez@novopayment.com
Add a Comment

Replies

Turns out that adding BUILD_LIBRARY_FOR_DISTRIBUTION = YES to the end of the xcodebuild command was not enough / not working to produce a framework with the required swiftinterface files. I had to go in the settings for the actual project and manually set BUILD_LIBRARY_FOR_DISTRIBUTION to YES, like this answer suggests, then I was able to get frameworks with the swiftinterface files. After I got the frameworks with the swiftinterface files, I was then able to create the xcframework file using xcodebuild without any problems.

Posted by
pkoggg2
Up vote reply of pkoggg2 Down vote reply of pkoggg2
Post marked as solved

  • I work this solution; I opened the xcode and I searched BUILD_LIBRARY_FOR_DISTRIBUTION in Buid setings and changed to "YES" I deleted platform-specific and rebiuld again

    —
    annunez@novopayment.com
Add a Comment
The setting is BUILD_LIBRARY_FOR_DISTRIBUTION. Singular not plural. I was running into this as well and just coded it up.
Posted by
dpfannenstiel
Post not yet marked as solved Up vote reply of dpfannenstiel Down vote reply of dpfannenstiel
Add a Comment

Hi, I have a static library with cocoa-pods e.g. Alamofire. When the library is built, respective Alamofire.framework is generated in Debug-iphoneos and Debug-iphonesimulator folders. I am trying to generate xcframework from those two using xcodebuild -create-xcframework. However just Info.plist is added in the Alamofire.xcframework folder. The _CodeSignature folder in Alamofire.framework for Debug-iphoneos is missing and I doubt this is the reason for not having ios-arm64 and ios-x86_64-simulator with respective .framework in the xcframework

If I create my own framework and generate xcframework e.g TestFramework.xcframework does have Info.plist, ios-arm64 and ios-x86_64-simulator with respective TestFramework.framework

I would be grateful if someone helps me understanding and resolving the issue.

Thanks & Regards

Posted by
SKDev13
Up vote reply of SKDev13 Down vote reply of SKDev13
Add a Comment

Alternatively

If you're doing this operation often, or if you wanted to automate (CI/CD) this process you can also use the CLI tool Surmagic https://github.com/gurhub/surmagic.

Posted by
mgy
Up vote reply of mgy Down vote reply of mgy
Add a Comment

As mentioned earlier, you made a typo

# Archive for device
xcodebuild archive -scheme TestFramework -destination="iOS" -archivePath /tmp/xcf/ios.xcarchive -derivedDataPath /tmp/iphoneos -sdk iphoneos SKIP_INSTALL=NO BUILD_LIBRARIES_FOR_DISTRIBUTION=YES


# Archive for simulator
xcodebuild archive -scheme TestFramework -destination="iOS Simulator" -archivePath /tmp/xcf/iossimulator.xcarchive -derivedDataPath /tmp/iphoneos -sdk iphonesimulator SKIP_INSTALL=NO BUILD_LIBRARIES_FOR_DISTRIBUTION=YES

You should use BUILD_LIBRARY_FOR_DISTRIBUTION instead of BUILD_LIBRARIES_FOR_DISTRIBUTION.

Library Evolution in Swift

https://xcodebuildsettings.com/#build_library_for_distribution

Posted by
algashev
Up vote reply of algashev Down vote reply of algashev
Add a Comment

https://github.com/awasthi027/Xcode_lib_framework_issues/blob/master/README.md

Posted by
Ashi027
Up vote reply of Ashi027 Down vote reply of Ashi027
Add a Comment