Hi everyone!
Adam here, the developer of Albums. Bummed not to get to have our yearly WebEx reunion where I beg y’all to add an endpoint to the Apple Music API to allow deleting items from a user’s library. But that’s not what this thread is about.
Back in October, thanks to your team’s multi-year efforts, I was finally able to ship Albums for macOS. It’s been a genuine dream come true to use it on the platform I always envisioned it on, and I hear from users all the time who feel the same way. I know it was a significant engineering effort, and I’m genuinely very grateful.
I’ll be judicious with my time here (I’d love to chat in more detail about my adventures in MusicKit on the Mac somehow, sometime). These are the main things on my wishlist for MusicKit on the Mac.
There are three main things I hear from users that my app “can’t do” that can be dealbreakers for them.
The first two are AirPlay support and a volume slider. Users are only able to AirPlay using the control center utility, because AVRoutePickerView does not work with ApplicationMusicPlayer (FB13934910). Relatedly, the MPVolumeView does not work with ApplicationMusicPlayer (FB21042385), so I can’t allow users app-specific volume control for my app.
The lack of those two things is a real detriment to my app being able to be taken seriously alongside all of the other music player apps on the platform for which those features are table stakes. I know there’s a challenge here given the playback actually happens in the subprocess, but hoping some progress can be made here.
The other issue is that library tracks played in ApplicationMusicPlayer do not update the last played date or play count in Music.app or in the user’s iCloud Music Library (FB17675148). Some people refuse to use the app for that reason, and I can’t say I blame them. I’ve only been able to test this briefly in Golden Gate, but it seems like this is still the case. Are you able to share anything about your work on the music library in macOS this year?
Thank you again for all your work on MusicKit! I’m planning to get the last of the load-bearing MediaPlayer code out of my codebase later this year. Hooray!
