32 days, five rejections, and still no App Store release

On November 20, I had to cancel my entire App Review submission just to delete two optional subscription images. After 32 days, my first independent iOS app is still unpublished, and I’m back in the review queue.

I’ve been releasing iOS apps for nine years, including under this Apple developer account. Yet my first submission was treated as if I had no development experience.

Here’s what a month of App Review looked like:

  • October 19: Submitted my app.
  • October 20: Rejected with a request for demonstration videos and additional explanations, apparently because this was my first app under my own developer account. No actual issues with the app were identified. I recorded the videos and provided the requested information.
  • November 3: After almost two weeks of waiting, rejected because App Store Connect hadn’t automatically included my existing subscriptions in the submission. I had to attach them manually.
  • November 4: Rejected again. I had already selected Apple’s Standard EULA in the dedicated License Agreement section, but App Review additionally required a Terms of Use link in the app description for all six localizations.
  • November 11: Another rejection. This time, Apple objected to my custom HealthKit pre-permission dialog because it offered a dismiss option. Their requirement effectively forced me to make the dialog non-dismissible, removing the user’s ability to decline at that stage. They also rejected two identical optional subscription promotional images.
  • November 11–12: I immediately fixed the HealthKit dialog and submitted an updated build. However, App Store Connect wouldn’t let me delete the promotional images while the subscriptions were awaiting review. I explained this to App Review, attached a screenshot, and explicitly asked for help. My reply was sent shortly after midnight on November 12.
  • November 19: Nine days later, rejected again for exactly the same images. My request for assistance was ignored.
  • November 20: I had to cancel the entire submission, including the app version, subscription group, and both subscriptions, just to unlock editing and delete two optional images. I created a new submission and returned to Waiting for Review.

Five rejections. Thirty-two days. A different issue raised at almost every review, rather than providing consolidated feedback.

I addressed the issues promptly, often within hours. Most of the month was spent waiting for Apple, not fixing the app.

And every rejection includes the same invitation:

If you have any questions, we are here to help. Reply to this message in App Store Connect and let us know.

I did. Nine days later, instead of help, I received the same rejection.

The App Store Connect interface only made matters worse: subscriptions must be manually attached to the initial submission, but their optional images become locked during review. Correcting them ultimately required canceling everything and submitting again.

Another developer reported a similar issue: https://developer.apple.com/forums/thread/829274

I have no objection to legitimate app review requirements. But is it reasonable to make an independent developer wait over a month while identifying issues one at a time, ignoring requests for help, and forcing a complete resubmission because of limitations in Apple’s own interface?

My app is still unpublished. After 32 days, I’m back where I started: Waiting for Review.

I also contacted Apple Developer Support about the prolonged review delays. Despite repeatedly explaining that my app had been stuck in the review process since October 19, the support representative, Shandy, kept assuring me that everything was “proceeding normally.”

On November 10, she confirmed that my case had been forwarded for investigation. A week later, I received another generic response saying the review was still proceeding normally, with no explanation of the delays or results of that investigation. It felt as though my messages weren’t being read, only answered with templates.

Hi! Your experience sounds remarkably similar to mine. I first submitted my app on October 23 and have also been through requests for demo videos, additional documentation, EULA links in all localizations, and issues with attaching subscriptions.

My latest submission has been stuck in "Waiting for Review" since November 12, and Developer Support hasn't responded yet.

I'm particularly interested in the subscription issue. On November 6, I successfully submitted all four items together: the app version, the subscription group, and both monthly and annual subscriptions.

However, after cancelling that submission, App Store Connect wouldn't let me attach the subscriptions to my new submission. They're now in a separate draft, ready for review, but I can't submit them because App Store Connect requires an app version to be included.

I've also updated my promotional subscription images after reading about your experience.

Did you manage to submit all four items together again after cancelling everything? If so, what steps did you follow? I'm reluctant to cancel my current submission after waiting eight days, especially since I couldn't resolve this issue after previous cancellations.

Also, did you ever try requesting an expedited review? Did it make any difference?

Thanks for sharing your experience. It's frustrating to see so many of us going through the same thing.

Same boat. I originally submitted my App for review the first week of October. Immediately, auto-rejected asking for screen caps, video, etc... Fine - did it and resubmitted with some additions on Oct 13. Was in Waiting for Review for 16 days before being rejected b/c of an icon issue.

Fixing the icon required my closing the original submission and filing a completely new one which I did on Oct 30. I'm still in Waiting for Revew today, Nov 20 - three weeks later :(

My app remains unpublished after 45+ days of Waiting for Review