A similar, but different (?) mail problem?

This seems slightly different from the Mal problems I've seen so I thought I'd make a separate post. I've had similar problems every time they do a major overhaul of Mail and OS at the same time.


Mail tries to import the mail which is supposedly 225K e-mails. I don't believe it is that high, I believe it is 1/4-1/2 that, but some of them have gotten duplicated by Mail's bizarre system. Mail has always worked pretty well despite its weirdness and I couldn't find a decent alternative.


In any case, it get to 52K something e-mails and always stops in the same place and hangs up. If I cancel, it closes. If I let it go, it eventually gives me an error message and you have to close it. For some reason, Apple doesn't let you open the program and then LET you import your emails, it forces you to, and that makes it a whole lot more difficult to diagnose.


I've been slowing tryng some of these tricks of moving or deleting files/folders, not wanting to go too far and get in a mess, but so far, the process repeats exactly. The odd thing is that the files all appear to have been moved to V3 folder. And this is the new folder, correct?

So the question is if there are any other ideas? It just hung up at 52K yet again.

The mail has, indeed, all been moved to V3 folder and the V2 I've moved to the trash. I just need a way to get this to do an import. Should I move the folders to the desktop and attemp to import them from this? I'm going to try to move them to my other laptop and import that way.

Hi John,


You may find this thread interesting: https://forums.developer.apple.com/thread/19660

As I mention there, this is always so much messier and imperfect than one would hope. There are lots of mailbox related tricks, but I don't blame you for being reluctant to go down that road - it rarely ends with 100% success. Fwiw though (and you proably already realise this) you can open Mail in Safe Mode by holding shift while clicking the icon in the dock. Like that you can make changes without Mail forcing you to do anything.


-Max

There are quite a few reports on here of doing just that - moving out of V3 just to import back in again - and the results are mixed. Some lose their mail folder structure and some don't. There are also other, less consequential, glitches that can occur but hopefully it'll all work out for you 🙂

I guess the big thing is if we know the root cause? I've run into this before and of course, my mailbox system ended up being a mess because of it with Mail mediculously making duplicates that I can't prevent. So far, none of the things I've seen has fixed the issue, so I don't know if it doesn't like my mail box files? Is it a glitch with Mail/El Capitan? Or is this just typical BS Apple does, because it's definitely happened to be before and I had to import and deal with thei consequences.

FWIW, my old laptop computer (now for pictures and other non-business apps) is importing all of my old email boxes, it seems. But blocking the V3 bailboxes allowed me to restart and import messages from the internet, which won't cover nearly all, but that's okay as it will no doubt free up 25-40GB of space. I just temporarily renamed V3 and once I am sure the old computer has imported properly, I can delete the whole thing. This is a bit of serendipity for me as this was sort of the general plan anyway, but it would be infuriating otherwise. It will be nice to know that Apple actually fixes this so I don't have to go through it every 2-3 years. Of course, the new thing as I type this is that Mail is now crashing. I assume they have to fix THAT at some point.

Sadly these threads end like this more often than not, for the reasons outlined here and in the thread linked to above. Wishing you the best of luck with your Mail woes 😐

A similar, but different (?) mail problem?
 
 
Q