ello everyone,
I'm looking for advice from developers who have experienced repeated App Store rejections under Guideline 4.3(a), particularly in situations involving a previously published version of the same organization's application under another developer account.
I'm developing and publishing an officially authorized application for Arise and Shine Heavenly Embassy. Unfortunately, I've been caught in a prolonged App Review process, and I'm struggling to find a clear path toward resolving the issue.
Background
There was a previous Arise & Shine application published under a former developer's Apple Developer account.
I subsequently developed a new version of the application under my own Apple Developer account, with authorization from the organization.
During the review process, Apple repeatedly rejected the new application under Guideline 4.3(a) – Spam.
I understand Apple's concerns about duplicate applications and appreciate the need to maintain quality on the App Store. However, I have been trying to resolve this matter in good faith.
What I've done so far
Communicated with Apple App Review regarding the rejection.
Attended a discussion with an Apple representative to understand the concerns.
Followed the instructions to investigate and remove the previous application.
Accessed the former developer's account and attempted to remove the previous application.
Discovered that the removal could not be completed because the former developer's Apple Developer Program membership had expired.
Explained this limitation to Apple and provided supporting evidence.
Was subsequently encouraged to resubmit the application, which I did in good faith.
Unfortunately, the application was rejected again under the same guideline.
What makes this particularly difficult is that I still haven't received a sufficiently specific explanation of what exactly is triggering Guideline 4.3(a), or what concrete changes Apple expects me to make.
Where I need help
I would appreciate insights from developers who have experienced similar situations.
Specifically:
Can an application be rejected under Guideline 4.3(a) because a previous version of the same organization's app remains on the App Store under another developer account?
If the previous developer's membership has expired and the application cannot be removed through that account, what is the appropriate process for resolving this?
Is there an established procedure for transferring an application or resolving duplicate-app concerns when the original developer account is no longer active?
How can a developer get a case escalated to an App Review specialist who can examine the complete history of previous discussions and submissions?
I have also requested another phone call with App Review because I believe a direct discussion would be more productive than continuing through repeated rejections without specific guidance.
What I'm hoping to achieve
I am not asking Apple to overlook its guidelines or grant special treatment. I simply want to understand the precise issue, follow the appropriate procedure, and get this officially authorized application reviewed on its actual merits.
I've invested considerable time and resources into this project, and it is frustrating to remain stuck despite making genuine efforts to cooperate.
If anyone from the developer community has navigated a similar situation, I would genuinely appreciate hearing how you resolved it.
Thank you.