I'm an algo engineer-turned-entrepreneur. About two months ago, I signed up for the Apple Developer Program. Last month, I launched an AI avatar video calling app called Twome (pronounced "Two-me") on the App Store. But just a few days after launch, I used EAS Update (a React Native tool for hot updates) to push a quick bug fix, and soon after, I got hit with a "Pending Termination Notice." They said I violated the Apple Developer Agreement—my app got pulled, and my developer account was flagged for removal. (The App Review message was pretty vague: "App submissions from your account have engaged in concept or feature switch schemes to evade the review process." I'm guessing that's what triggered it.)
I was totally shocked. I'd done my homework beforehand and seen tons of devs saying hot updates for bug fixes were fine. No choice but to appeal, so I filed one right away on the App Review Board.
Then came the real nightmare: 28 whole days later, I finally got a response—and they upheld the rejection. The reasoning was even fuzzier this time; it felt like a copy-paste template. No specific evidence like before (at least the first notice had some details). Maybe they realized our update didn't actually change any features? Anyway, I'm trying another appeal now, but who knows when it'll come back. The waiting is brutal.
We did a full internal audit and pinpointed just two things that might've raised red flags with App Review:
-
Post-launch, we tested an unreleased "rate us" feature and posted a review using our developer account. We figured the App Store would know it was from the app owner and auto-remove it from public view. It was our only review, and we didn't think it'd count as misleading since Apple handles that stuff.
-
The bug fix hot update I mentioned.
Beyond that, our post-mortem showed zero other issues. All metadata, product descriptions, and screenshots are 100% compliant—no misleading claims, no dark patterns pushing payments, nothing.
Before launch, friends were hyped, saying it'd blow up—it's the world's first realistic AI digital human real-time video calling app for everyday social/entertainment use, aimed at regular folks. But now we're tied up in knots with this appeal mess, desperate to get back on the Store ASAP.
It's insane that appeals take a full month to get a response—especially when we didn't blatantly violate anything, or at worst, tripped over something unintentionally. We've already been down for over a month without even knowing the exact issue. Feels way too harsh.
Posting here to ask: Has anyone dealt with something similar? Is a 28-day wait (or more) normal for appeals? Any ways to expedite the process?
Any practical advice would be hugely appreciated!