Refund requests in the testing environment are never approved, only DECLINE resolves (consumables, non-renewing subscription) – FB25652374

We are testing refunds for consumables and a non-renewing subscription, installed from TestFlight (tester's own Apple Account, storefront VNM, iPhone 15, iOS 27.0.1), with App Store Server Notifications V2 on the sandbox URL.

"Testing refund requests" says: "select any refund reason on the refund request sheet, and submit the sheet. The App Store automatically approves the refund request in the testing environment." What we see:

  • DECLINE resolves every time, about 8 minutes after the CONSUMPTION_REQUEST: REFUND_DECLINED arrives whether our server answers refundPreference: DECLINE or the tester types DECLINE under Issue > Other.
  • Nothing else resolves, for up to 43 hours so far (11 requests): no REFUND notification, no revocationDate in Get Transaction Info, empty Get Refund History. This covers:
    • a listed reason with our server answering without refundPreference, answering GRANT_FULL (Send Consumption Information V2, inside the 5-minute window, 202), or not answering;
    • GRANT_PRORATED and GRANT_FULL typed under Issue > Other.
  • Every CONSUMPTION_REQUEST has consumptionRequestReason UNINTENDED_PURCHASE, even when the tester chose Issue > Other.

Questions:

  1. Should a refund request in the testing environment be approved when the server answers without a preference, answers GRANT_FULL, or does not answer?
  2. Is the GRANT_PRORATED keyword still supported?
  3. Does refund testing require a Sandbox Apple Account instead of a TestFlight install?

Full details, transaction IDs and decoded notification history are in FB25652374. Thread 743381 looks similar.