Delve into the world of graphics and game development. Discuss creating stunning visuals, optimizing game mechanics, and share resources for game developers.

Posts under General subtopic

Post

Replies

Boosts

Views

Activity

Metal, Vulkan, OpenGL & Godot
Greetings! I'm preparing to publish an app in Apple Store. It's a 2D Audio app made in Godot, already published in Google Store.. As we know, OpenGL is considered deprecated since iOS 12 / 2018 .. However given the current state of Metal, or Vulkan integration in Godot, and with the idea of bringing the Best possible experience on iOS.. I'm not completely sure what will be the best API to use as primary option.. -As good as Metal, or even Vulkan work in Godot; the fact of the matter is, each API has its strong and weak points.. -Metal: Native on iOS, fully compliant and supported. However it has two weak points: Initial Compilation Freeze - +5 sec. Performance Hit, (although negligible for final user) app uses 25% more CPU (on my iPhone 12). Battery drain? -Vulkan: In godot, Vulkan > MoltenVk > Metal More complex translation layer, but interestingly gives slightly better Performance than Metal.. Initial Compilation doesn't cause Freeze, because is lazy/delayed and performed while the app is starting. Uses 25% less CPU than Metal and gives slightly more stable Framerate. (iPhone 12) However, given the extra complexity it could be more prone to error, or Compatibility Problems, which are known and have been reported with older iOS devices (iPads come to mind..) Right? -OpenGL: No Initial Compilation Needed Max Performance, No CPU munch Universally supported, (in theory?) works Perfectly on my iPhone 12 with iOS 26.3 and 26.4.2 And all in all, gives the best Performance and user experience. -And that's pretty much the situation! Since the graphics API of choice, will have an effect and directly translate to User experience... what's then the best one? -This will be the first app I Publish on Apple Store, so as you can imagine I want to Comply with Apple as much as possible; and bring iOS users the best possible experience. However each one of the APIs seem to have a negative aspect.. Metal: 5sec Compilation Freeze Vulkan: Compatibility Problems? OpenGL: "Deprecated" In practical terms, right now, OpenGL gives the best Performance, and the best User Experience.. So what to do? -The Android version is published in Google Store in OpenGL Compat mode. Works perfectly. Even tho OpenGL has been Deprecated on iOS for 7+ years, it has survived all along, with no announced removal date from Apple. And it seems to work perfectly and be fully operational up to the latest iOS 26 version.. right? Maybe Apple is maintaining it for stability and compatibility reasons, even if they're no longer actively developing it? Butthee "deprecated" label sounds alarming, as if support could drop any day.. So what will be the best choice in this situation? -Will an app built primarily for OpenGL, (with Metal fallback) be Rejected right away in Apple Store? -Otoh Vulkan (via MoltenVK) could be a middle term solution, second best Performance, no Compilation Freeze.. But yeah, the Compatibility aspect is important; and while considerable improvements have been made in Godot's implementation, the current status or possible outcome is harder to assess.. Both Metal and OpenGL seem safer options in that sense..
5
0
930
2w
Possibilities of Overclocking Apple Silicon
I've been testing Apple Silicon devices in their desktop configurations on the Mac Studio and now retired Mac Pro and it seems like they're greatly bottlenecked by their clock speeds. For reference here's my testing results. Testing Results: Mac Studio M2 Max • 32GBs RAM • 30 core GPU • 1TB Storage CPU Utilization • 60% • 20W CPU Temperature • 47ºC GPU Utilization • 100% • 20W GPU Temperature • 55ºC Fan Speed • 50% Workload Duration • 2hrs Another point is that the clock speed on the M2 Max's CPU is 3.5 GHz and on the GPU it is 1.44 GHz at max performance. Which the Mac Studio has no trouble pushing. My question is how do I push those clock speeds higher? Cause 1.44 GHz at 55ºC is evidence for extensive headroom. I'm sure there are tools internally for testing the upper limits of the silicon, but it makes no sense why it would be set so low the Mac Studio is at no worries of melting. Is there any way to push the performance of my Mac Studio? FB22713867 - Possibilities of Overclocking Apple Silicon
1
0
212
1w
HidHide on MacOS
I was wondering if there's a method on MacOS to have my application hide a hid device such as a game controller and instead have the receiving game/application see my app's virtual controller? Is this possible via DriverKit or some other form of kernel level coding? On Windows we have a tool known as HidHide that hids a game controller from all other applications. Is it possible to implement such behavior into an app or is that system level?
6
0
2.1k
1w
SwiftUI + SpriteKit interop: best practices for HUD overlays in a tile-based puzzle game?
Hey all, I'm building a tile-based puzzle game for iOS and have been experimenting with using SwiftUI for the HUD (score, timer, pause menu, settings sheet) layered on top of a SpriteView that hosts the actual gameplay scene. So far the integration has been smoother than I expected — SpriteView drops cleanly into a ZStack, and I can drive SwiftUI state from the SpriteKit scene via an ObservableObject shared between them. That said, I've run into a few rough edges that I'd love some input on. The biggest one is touch handling: when a SwiftUI overlay (like a semi-transparent pause button) sits over the SpriteView, taps near the edges of the button occasionally get swallowed by the underlying scene, even when the button's hit area looks correct in the view debugger. I've tried .contentShape(Rectangle()) and bumping the frame, which helps but doesn't fully eliminate it. Curious if anyone has landed on a reliable pattern here, especially for transient overlays like toast notifications that need to ignore touches everywhere except on the toast itself. The other thing I'm weighing is animation ownership. Right now, gameplay animations (tile slides, match effects) live in SpriteKit, and HUD animations (score pop, combo counter) live in SwiftUI with withAnimation. It works, but the two animation systems don't share a clock, so when I want a "tile matched → score increment" effect to feel synchronized, I end up dispatching from the SKScene back to the ObservableObject and hoping the frame timing lines up. Has anyone found a cleaner way to coordinate timing across the two, or is this just the cost of mixing the frameworks? Would also love to hear from anyone who has shipped a game with this hybrid setup — any gotchas around Scene Phase transitions, backgrounding, or memory pressure that bit you in production? Thanks!
0
0
869
1w
CGSetDisplayTransferByTable is broken on macOS Tahoe 26.4 RC (and 26.3.1) with MacBook M5 Pro, Max and Neo
The CGSetDisplayTransferByTable() is not working on the latest round of Mac hardware, namely the MacBook Neo (external display), MacBook M5 Pro (both built-in and external display) and possibly the M5 Max. All tested apps (BetterDisplay, MonitorControl, f.lux, Lunar) exhibit the very issue both in macOS Tahoe 26.3 and macOS Tahoe 26.4 RC. Tested on multiple Macs and installations on the MacBook Neo and MacBook M5 Pro. This issue breaks several display related macOS apps. Way to reproduce the issue using an affected app: Install the app BetterDisplay (https://betterdisplay.pro) Launch the app, open the app menu, choose Image Adjustments and try to adjust colors. Adjustments take no effect Way to reproduce the issue programmatically: Attempt to use the affected macOS API feature: https://developer.apple.com/documentation/coregraphics/cgsetdisplaytransferbytable(::::_:) Here are the FB numbers: FB22273730 (Filed this one as a developer on an unaffected MBP M3 Max) FB22273782 (Filed from an affected MBP M5 Pro running 26.4 RC, with debug info attached)
5
3
2.2k
2d
New GameSave API unexpected behavior
Hi, I'm implementing the new iOS 26 GameSave API in my game and I'm seeing an unexpected behavior when I try to handle custom conflict resolution. Here's what happens: directoryState.conflictedVersions is nil when directoryState.state is GSSyncStateConflicted. According to the API docs, this should never happen because there is no way to resolve the conflict. Here's the setup: I have 2 devices. Device 1 - iPad 10G iOS 26.5, and Device 2 - iPhone SE 3G iOS 26.5 and I run the same code on both devices. I disable the WiFi on device 2 to create a conflict I open the directory using [GSSyncedDirectory openDirectoryForContainerIdentifier: nil] Run [dir finishSyncingWithCompletionHandler:] After the callback returns I check dir.directoryState.state If the state is GSSyncStateReady, GSSyncStateOffline, or GSSyncStateLocal I write some data in a file and close the dir. I re-enable the WiFi on Device 2 and run the same code Now, on Device 2 dir.directoryState.state is GSSyncStateConflicted, as expected, but dir.directoryState.conflictedVersions is NIL and there is no way to continue and resolve the conflict. I'm expecting dir.directoryState.conflictedVersions to contain an array of GSSyncedDirectoryVersion objects as described in the API docs. One interesting bit is that if I replace [dir finishSyncingWithCompletionHandler:] with [dir finishSyncing: window completionHandler:] the UI conflict resolution works as expected. I'm using Objective C to call the API, if that matters. I've also reported via Feedback Assistant with Feedback Number: FB22790831
0
0
309
2d
Please, implement the new GameSave framework on tvOS
Hi, I have a game which is available on iOS and tvOS and the gameplay is basically the same on both platforms. I'd like to enable my players to seamlessly continue their play sessions on all available platforms. Unfortunately, the new GameSave framework is not available on tvOS and neither is the old GKSavedGame API. I'm asking you to enable the new GameSave framework in a future version of tvOS. Thank you. I've also reported via Feedback Assistant with Feedback Number: FB22791051
1
0
314
1d
Metal, Vulkan, OpenGL & Godot
Greetings! I'm preparing to publish an app in Apple Store. It's a 2D Audio app made in Godot, already published in Google Store.. As we know, OpenGL is considered deprecated since iOS 12 / 2018 .. However given the current state of Metal, or Vulkan integration in Godot, and with the idea of bringing the Best possible experience on iOS.. I'm not completely sure what will be the best API to use as primary option.. -As good as Metal, or even Vulkan work in Godot; the fact of the matter is, each API has its strong and weak points.. -Metal: Native on iOS, fully compliant and supported. However it has two weak points: Initial Compilation Freeze - +5 sec. Performance Hit, (although negligible for final user) app uses 25% more CPU (on my iPhone 12). Battery drain? -Vulkan: In godot, Vulkan > MoltenVk > Metal More complex translation layer, but interestingly gives slightly better Performance than Metal.. Initial Compilation doesn't cause Freeze, because is lazy/delayed and performed while the app is starting. Uses 25% less CPU than Metal and gives slightly more stable Framerate. (iPhone 12) However, given the extra complexity it could be more prone to error, or Compatibility Problems, which are known and have been reported with older iOS devices (iPads come to mind..) Right? -OpenGL: No Initial Compilation Needed Max Performance, No CPU munch Universally supported, (in theory?) works Perfectly on my iPhone 12 with iOS 26.3 and 26.4.2 And all in all, gives the best Performance and user experience. -And that's pretty much the situation! Since the graphics API of choice, will have an effect and directly translate to User experience... what's then the best one? -This will be the first app I Publish on Apple Store, so as you can imagine I want to Comply with Apple as much as possible; and bring iOS users the best possible experience. However each one of the APIs seem to have a negative aspect.. Metal: 5sec Compilation Freeze Vulkan: Compatibility Problems? OpenGL: "Deprecated" In practical terms, right now, OpenGL gives the best Performance, and the best User Experience.. So what to do? -The Android version is published in Google Store in OpenGL Compat mode. Works perfectly. Even tho OpenGL has been Deprecated on iOS for 7+ years, it has survived all along, with no announced removal date from Apple. And it seems to work perfectly and be fully operational up to the latest iOS 26 version.. right? Maybe Apple is maintaining it for stability and compatibility reasons, even if they're no longer actively developing it? Butthee "deprecated" label sounds alarming, as if support could drop any day.. So what will be the best choice in this situation? -Will an app built primarily for OpenGL, (with Metal fallback) be Rejected right away in Apple Store? -Otoh Vulkan (via MoltenVK) could be a middle term solution, second best Performance, no Compilation Freeze.. But yeah, the Compatibility aspect is important; and while considerable improvements have been made in Godot's implementation, the current status or possible outcome is harder to assess.. Both Metal and OpenGL seem safer options in that sense..
Replies
5
Boosts
0
Views
930
Activity
2w
Possibilities of Overclocking Apple Silicon
I've been testing Apple Silicon devices in their desktop configurations on the Mac Studio and now retired Mac Pro and it seems like they're greatly bottlenecked by their clock speeds. For reference here's my testing results. Testing Results: Mac Studio M2 Max • 32GBs RAM • 30 core GPU • 1TB Storage CPU Utilization • 60% • 20W CPU Temperature • 47ºC GPU Utilization • 100% • 20W GPU Temperature • 55ºC Fan Speed • 50% Workload Duration • 2hrs Another point is that the clock speed on the M2 Max's CPU is 3.5 GHz and on the GPU it is 1.44 GHz at max performance. Which the Mac Studio has no trouble pushing. My question is how do I push those clock speeds higher? Cause 1.44 GHz at 55ºC is evidence for extensive headroom. I'm sure there are tools internally for testing the upper limits of the silicon, but it makes no sense why it would be set so low the Mac Studio is at no worries of melting. Is there any way to push the performance of my Mac Studio? FB22713867 - Possibilities of Overclocking Apple Silicon
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
212
Activity
1w
HidHide on MacOS
I was wondering if there's a method on MacOS to have my application hide a hid device such as a game controller and instead have the receiving game/application see my app's virtual controller? Is this possible via DriverKit or some other form of kernel level coding? On Windows we have a tool known as HidHide that hids a game controller from all other applications. Is it possible to implement such behavior into an app or is that system level?
Replies
6
Boosts
0
Views
2.1k
Activity
1w
SwiftUI + SpriteKit interop: best practices for HUD overlays in a tile-based puzzle game?
Hey all, I'm building a tile-based puzzle game for iOS and have been experimenting with using SwiftUI for the HUD (score, timer, pause menu, settings sheet) layered on top of a SpriteView that hosts the actual gameplay scene. So far the integration has been smoother than I expected — SpriteView drops cleanly into a ZStack, and I can drive SwiftUI state from the SpriteKit scene via an ObservableObject shared between them. That said, I've run into a few rough edges that I'd love some input on. The biggest one is touch handling: when a SwiftUI overlay (like a semi-transparent pause button) sits over the SpriteView, taps near the edges of the button occasionally get swallowed by the underlying scene, even when the button's hit area looks correct in the view debugger. I've tried .contentShape(Rectangle()) and bumping the frame, which helps but doesn't fully eliminate it. Curious if anyone has landed on a reliable pattern here, especially for transient overlays like toast notifications that need to ignore touches everywhere except on the toast itself. The other thing I'm weighing is animation ownership. Right now, gameplay animations (tile slides, match effects) live in SpriteKit, and HUD animations (score pop, combo counter) live in SwiftUI with withAnimation. It works, but the two animation systems don't share a clock, so when I want a "tile matched → score increment" effect to feel synchronized, I end up dispatching from the SKScene back to the ObservableObject and hoping the frame timing lines up. Has anyone found a cleaner way to coordinate timing across the two, or is this just the cost of mixing the frameworks? Would also love to hear from anyone who has shipped a game with this hybrid setup — any gotchas around Scene Phase transitions, backgrounding, or memory pressure that bit you in production? Thanks!
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
869
Activity
1w
CGSetDisplayTransferByTable is broken on macOS Tahoe 26.4 RC (and 26.3.1) with MacBook M5 Pro, Max and Neo
The CGSetDisplayTransferByTable() is not working on the latest round of Mac hardware, namely the MacBook Neo (external display), MacBook M5 Pro (both built-in and external display) and possibly the M5 Max. All tested apps (BetterDisplay, MonitorControl, f.lux, Lunar) exhibit the very issue both in macOS Tahoe 26.3 and macOS Tahoe 26.4 RC. Tested on multiple Macs and installations on the MacBook Neo and MacBook M5 Pro. This issue breaks several display related macOS apps. Way to reproduce the issue using an affected app: Install the app BetterDisplay (https://betterdisplay.pro) Launch the app, open the app menu, choose Image Adjustments and try to adjust colors. Adjustments take no effect Way to reproduce the issue programmatically: Attempt to use the affected macOS API feature: https://developer.apple.com/documentation/coregraphics/cgsetdisplaytransferbytable(::::_:) Here are the FB numbers: FB22273730 (Filed this one as a developer on an unaffected MBP M3 Max) FB22273782 (Filed from an affected MBP M5 Pro running 26.4 RC, with debug info attached)
Replies
5
Boosts
3
Views
2.2k
Activity
2d
New GameSave API unexpected behavior
Hi, I'm implementing the new iOS 26 GameSave API in my game and I'm seeing an unexpected behavior when I try to handle custom conflict resolution. Here's what happens: directoryState.conflictedVersions is nil when directoryState.state is GSSyncStateConflicted. According to the API docs, this should never happen because there is no way to resolve the conflict. Here's the setup: I have 2 devices. Device 1 - iPad 10G iOS 26.5, and Device 2 - iPhone SE 3G iOS 26.5 and I run the same code on both devices. I disable the WiFi on device 2 to create a conflict I open the directory using [GSSyncedDirectory openDirectoryForContainerIdentifier: nil] Run [dir finishSyncingWithCompletionHandler:] After the callback returns I check dir.directoryState.state If the state is GSSyncStateReady, GSSyncStateOffline, or GSSyncStateLocal I write some data in a file and close the dir. I re-enable the WiFi on Device 2 and run the same code Now, on Device 2 dir.directoryState.state is GSSyncStateConflicted, as expected, but dir.directoryState.conflictedVersions is NIL and there is no way to continue and resolve the conflict. I'm expecting dir.directoryState.conflictedVersions to contain an array of GSSyncedDirectoryVersion objects as described in the API docs. One interesting bit is that if I replace [dir finishSyncingWithCompletionHandler:] with [dir finishSyncing: window completionHandler:] the UI conflict resolution works as expected. I'm using Objective C to call the API, if that matters. I've also reported via Feedback Assistant with Feedback Number: FB22790831
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
309
Activity
2d
Please, implement the new GameSave framework on tvOS
Hi, I have a game which is available on iOS and tvOS and the gameplay is basically the same on both platforms. I'd like to enable my players to seamlessly continue their play sessions on all available platforms. Unfortunately, the new GameSave framework is not available on tvOS and neither is the old GKSavedGame API. I'm asking you to enable the new GameSave framework in a future version of tvOS. Thank you. I've also reported via Feedback Assistant with Feedback Number: FB22791051
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
314
Activity
1d