Cannot Re-add Subscriptions and IAPs After Removing Them from Rejected App Submission

Hi,

My app, HarpLegend, was rejected under Guidelines 2.3.2 and 2.3.10. The rejection required changes to my promotional images and purchase metadata.

However, only the app version was rejected, while my two auto-renewable subscriptions (Monthly and Yearly) and one non-consumable IAP (Lifetime) remained in "Ready for Review" status. As a result, I was unable to edit their promotional images, display names, or descriptions, since these fields were read-only in App Store Connect.

To make the corrections, I removed all three products from the existing submission. After successfully updating their metadata and promotional images, I attempted to add them back, but all three now return:

"Unable to Add for Review — Something went wrong. Try again."

The original submission still shows all three products as "Removed," while the app version and subscription group remain "Ready for Review."

I've found several related discussions:

My questions are:

  1. Has anyone successfully resolved this issue without removing the app version from the existing submission?
  2. If I remove the app version, will I be able to add for review again including the subscription group, both subscriptions, and the Lifetime IAP?
  3. Is there a way to resolve this without restarting the review process?

I originally submitted my app on October 13, over five weeks ago, I had to cancel and restart the process two times already and would really like to avoid another lengthy wait.

I've already replied to my App Review but haven't received a response yet.

Any advice would be greatly appreciated. Thanks!

Ran into the same "something went wrong" error when re-adding IAPs to a submission. What worked for me: in App Store Connect, open the old rejected submission and remove the app version from it. After that the IAPs and subscription group became attachable again, and I was able to create a fresh submission with them. I haven't got through review on the new submission yet, so I can't say it's fully clean, but it got me past the lock. Might be worth trying, since your products are already removed from the old one.