Search results for

“copycat”

162 results found

Post

Replies

Boosts

Views

Activity

Copycats?But ODIKING belongs to us!
Hi,After I tried to submit my APP for review several times, it was still rejected for the following reasons: Guideline 4.1-Design-Copycats: The app or its metadata appears to contain potentially misleading content. Specifically, the app includes content that resembles ODIKING without the necessary authorization. But odiking belongs to our company's product, I don't know the problem, I don't understand how to prove that this product does not belong to a third party content Tanks1
Topic: Design SubTopic: General
0
0
295
Oct ’24
4. 1 Design: Copycats (iOS)
My App was rejected with this reason Design: Copycats (iOS).Now I do not know what the real reason is. On a screenshot you can see a piece of a car, but you can not tell what kind of car that is.Can the car be the reason?Or does the icon look similar to other apps? It is a collage app. All collage app icons look similar. But not exactly the same.I really do not know what to do. I spent two months development time, 2000 $ for translations and designer. And now this surprise.Full message:----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------4. 1 Design: Copycats (iOS)Guideline 4.1 - DesignYour app or its metadata appears to contain misleading content.Specifically, your app includes content that resembles third-party apps that are live on the App Store.Next StepsTo resolve this issue, please make the necessary changes to your app so that it does not infringe upon the rights of a third party:- Remove all third-party marks from your app icon, screenshots, a
7
0
12k
Mar ’17
Design: Copycats 4.1 - iOS
Hello, My mobile game 'Wordilo' has been rejected due to Design: Copycats 4.1. I am reviewing the mentioned warnings, but my application does not contain any direct elements that could be considered a copy of a known game, apart from the core game mechanics. The game mechanic is a crossword puzzle, and there are already many apps with this game logic on the App Store. For example, the rules and style of a backgammon game are well-established, and there are many similar games based on this. I need more specific guidance in this regard. Thank you.
1
0
446
Dec ’24
Guideline 4.1 - Design - Copycats: What is metadata?
Hello community, My game was rejected review with the following message: Guideline 4.1 - Design - Copycats Your metadata appears to contain third-party content. Specifically, [game name]. I'm here to ask you what is metadata? Is this message related to: 1) the data showed on the App Store page (e.g. Screenshots, Description, Search Keys) 2) or to the data inside the game (e.g. UI, assets, music, etc..) Thank you for help!
1
0
828
May ’21
4.1 Design-Copycats: What does that mean?
Hello. I made an app that serves as a checklist to help find special items in one of the Resident Evil games. The app displays a large number of screenshots of the game, illustrating where each item can be found. Because of this, Apple's reviewer rejected the app for copycat reasons. The alleged reason is described below:Guideline 4.1 - Design - CopycatsYour app or its metadata appears to contain misleading content.Specifically, your app includes content that resembles Resident Evil Revelations without the necessary authorization.What does that mean? That I can't include screenshots of others games in my app? Is there any way to get around this problem while still using screenshots?
1
0
1.6k
Feb ’20
App not accepted - 4.1 Copycats
Hi, I have some simple apps that uses memes of differents subjects like: politics, soccer and Big Brother(a program TV). There, you can share, favorite and contribuite of memes you have sending them to the app creatina a colaborative environment. After weeks of working on iOS version, i just have Android versions published, i sent to Apple Store evaluation and recieved as return 4.1 Copycats. In summary, i just know clearly If this kind of app is not accepted on Store and why.
0
0
415
Apr ’21
My app gets rejected for being a Copycat
Hello! I have an app on the Google Play Store called Concept.TF, and I decided to add it to the Apple App Store as well, but it got rejected. The purpose of the app is to create weapon ideas for a game called Team Fortress 2 and share them with your friends, so it is supposed to include Team Fortress 2 content. There are two things that I don't understand: Why was I able to submit the app on the Google Play Store? I understand that there are different rules for different platforms, but being a Copycat seems like a rather broad concept that both platforms would have. And how would I be eligible to use the Team Fortress 2 content on the App Store? Do I need to contact the developers of the game to get a license, etc. I will not link Concept.TF because I am not trying to promote the app, but if you go to the Google Play Store and search for it by name, it will be the first result.
1
0
511
Mar ’22
My first App Rejected. Copycat??
Trying to submit my first app to Apple but they won't accept it. Under the term 4.1.1 Copycat. Saying I don't have the rights or need to give proof I have the rights to use. I asked if this was good enough: section 107 of U.S. Copyright Act under the Fair Use and clearly state the intended purpose of the app is as a Parody or Satire of the third party content. They respond with ask forum and read the apple review guide which actually echoes what I said: Section 1 Safety 1.1.1. Professional political satirists and humorists are generally exempt from this requirement. But that is in regards to: harm, tasteful choices, and etc. To make things even odder. Google already accepted and published my app. https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.crystalmagic.starshiplauncher Can someone please clear up the confusion? :)
1
0
287
Mar ’25
Rejected for Guideline 4.1(c) Copycats
Hello everyone, I’m looking for some clarification and advice regarding an unexpected App Review rejection under Guideline 4.1 – Copycats. My app has been live on the App Store since May 2024, and during that time, it has maintained the same core flow, structure, UI, and feature set. There have been no major redesigns or attempts to imitate any other app. Recently, I submitted a new version (v3.2) with only minor changes related to ad logic implementation (no UI/UX changes, no branding changes, no metadata changes). However, this update was rejected with the following reason: “This app or its metadata appears to be misrepresenting itself as another popular app or game…” This has left me quite confused for a few reasons: The app has been approved and publicly available for nearly 2 years There were no significant design or branding changes in this submission The rejection seems unrelated to the actual changes made in this version My questions: Has anyone experienced a situation where an app was flagge
2
0
313
Mar ’26
CopyCat Rejection - what documents are required to verify that the app is mine?
Hello. I've tried a dozen times to upload my app, each time getting a response that the app was rejected due to 4.1 copycats. The most recent response: Guideline 4.1 - Design - Copycats. This app or its metadata appears to be misrepresenting itself as another popular app or game already available on the App Store, from a developer's website or distribution source, or from a third-party platform. On my requests to clarify what exactly was identified as copycats, no specifics were given to me. Because of this I conclude that it is not about some stock images or sound assets, but that it is specifically about my application (name and icon). I am the solo developer of the app and it has been available for 5 years on Google Play. No other platforms have my app on them, only Google Play. Since Apple has not provided me with specifics about what they need as proof of rights to the app, I have screen recorded my personal Google Play Developer Console account, which proves that I have all th
3
0
2.2k
Apr ’24
Please help me to understand the situation on Copycats problem of app
Hello, Our application has been rejected for many time now, and the reason is Design - Copycats. Well we spent so many time to create this app and now can't publish it. So can you please help to resolve this issue, what can be the problem? and how to resolve it? I don't know if it's our assets or anything.Thanks in advance. The review response is same all the time as follow;----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Guideline 4.1 - Design - CopycatsThis app or its metadata appears to be attempting to misrepresent itself as another popular app or game already available on the App Store or a third-party platform.Apps submitted to the App Store should be unique and should not attempt to d
5
0
3.1k
Feb ’19
4.1.0 Design: Copycats
For several months now, I have been trying to publish my app in the store, but I keep encountering the same copycat error. Since I started, I have modified absolutely everything in the game, yet I am consistently rejected without any explanation, even when I send messages. It is very frustrating to keep improving my game and always face the same situation. Could you help me and at least tell me what changes or improvements I need to make? Changes in My Game Licenses and Templates: Gunny Rush uses templates with all the necessary licenses. Unique Characters: We have five unique characters, animated from scratch by our team. Character Verification: We have implemented a verification system that allows users to use characters they own in their wallets within the game. Point Multiplier System: The more Inugis (characters) players have in the game, the higher the multiplier, and the more points they will earn per game. Dynamic Levels: Levels update dynamically as the player progresses through the game. Cu
1
0
445
Aug ’24
iOS App Store app copycats during delayed release/beta testing
I have an app approved by Apple waiting to be released while I collect more advance users through my landing page. I am worried about someone making a copycat app with the exact name and getting approved by Apple. For example, let's say my app is named Liquid - Dynamic Workout (the real name is slightly more unique). Could someone release an app before my set release date that is a copycat titled Liquid Workout? Additionally, for example, the domain liquidworkout.com is being squatted on, so I had to register liquidworkouts.com.Basically, if my app is already approved by Apple for app store release, and is on TestFlight, can someone still submit an app with a similar name, similar logo, and the same function? Do the copycat guidelines still apply? https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/#copycatsP.S. My app is based around a singular, unique function. I've looked through tens, maybe hundreds, of related apps.
2
0
1.8k
Jan ’18
4.1 Copycat when use content from an API
Hi,I've build an app who uses content from Wikia Fandom API.The app display characters and episodes from Rick and Morty.Of course I do not own the rights from Rick and Morty characters, but I can have the rights to use content who comes from Wikia API.My App is free of charge and do note make any money of it.How can my app be rejected for copycat reason ?It's like IMDB was rejected because it's displaying movie poster and don't own the right of the show ?Here the content of the rejection reason :Your app or its metadata appears to contain misleading content.Specifically, your app includes content that resembles “Rick and Morty” without the necessary authorization. It would be appropriate to remove all resembling content from the metadata.What do you think about it ? How can can I change that ?To be clear, my app screenshots, are in app screenshot displaying Rick and Morty characters.
2
0
747
Oct ’17
Copycats?But ODIKING belongs to us!
Hi,After I tried to submit my APP for review several times, it was still rejected for the following reasons: Guideline 4.1-Design-Copycats: The app or its metadata appears to contain potentially misleading content. Specifically, the app includes content that resembles ODIKING without the necessary authorization. But odiking belongs to our company's product, I don't know the problem, I don't understand how to prove that this product does not belong to a third party content Tanks1
Topic: Design SubTopic: General
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
295
Activity
Oct ’24
4. 1 Design: Copycats (iOS)
My App was rejected with this reason Design: Copycats (iOS).Now I do not know what the real reason is. On a screenshot you can see a piece of a car, but you can not tell what kind of car that is.Can the car be the reason?Or does the icon look similar to other apps? It is a collage app. All collage app icons look similar. But not exactly the same.I really do not know what to do. I spent two months development time, 2000 $ for translations and designer. And now this surprise.Full message:----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------4. 1 Design: Copycats (iOS)Guideline 4.1 - DesignYour app or its metadata appears to contain misleading content.Specifically, your app includes content that resembles third-party apps that are live on the App Store.Next StepsTo resolve this issue, please make the necessary changes to your app so that it does not infringe upon the rights of a third party:- Remove all third-party marks from your app icon, screenshots, a
Replies
7
Boosts
0
Views
12k
Activity
Mar ’17
Design: Copycats 4.1 - iOS
Hello, My mobile game 'Wordilo' has been rejected due to Design: Copycats 4.1. I am reviewing the mentioned warnings, but my application does not contain any direct elements that could be considered a copy of a known game, apart from the core game mechanics. The game mechanic is a crossword puzzle, and there are already many apps with this game logic on the App Store. For example, the rules and style of a backgammon game are well-established, and there are many similar games based on this. I need more specific guidance in this regard. Thank you.
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
446
Activity
Dec ’24
Guideline 4.1 - Design - Copycats: What is metadata?
Hello community, My game was rejected review with the following message: Guideline 4.1 - Design - Copycats Your metadata appears to contain third-party content. Specifically, [game name]. I'm here to ask you what is metadata? Is this message related to: 1) the data showed on the App Store page (e.g. Screenshots, Description, Search Keys) 2) or to the data inside the game (e.g. UI, assets, music, etc..) Thank you for help!
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
828
Activity
May ’21
4.1 Design-Copycats: What does that mean?
Hello. I made an app that serves as a checklist to help find special items in one of the Resident Evil games. The app displays a large number of screenshots of the game, illustrating where each item can be found. Because of this, Apple's reviewer rejected the app for copycat reasons. The alleged reason is described below:Guideline 4.1 - Design - CopycatsYour app or its metadata appears to contain misleading content.Specifically, your app includes content that resembles Resident Evil Revelations without the necessary authorization.What does that mean? That I can't include screenshots of others games in my app? Is there any way to get around this problem while still using screenshots?
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
1.6k
Activity
Feb ’20
App not accepted - 4.1 Copycats
Hi, I have some simple apps that uses memes of differents subjects like: politics, soccer and Big Brother(a program TV). There, you can share, favorite and contribuite of memes you have sending them to the app creatina a colaborative environment. After weeks of working on iOS version, i just have Android versions published, i sent to Apple Store evaluation and recieved as return 4.1 Copycats. In summary, i just know clearly If this kind of app is not accepted on Store and why.
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
415
Activity
Apr ’21
My app gets rejected for being a Copycat
Hello! I have an app on the Google Play Store called Concept.TF, and I decided to add it to the Apple App Store as well, but it got rejected. The purpose of the app is to create weapon ideas for a game called Team Fortress 2 and share them with your friends, so it is supposed to include Team Fortress 2 content. There are two things that I don't understand: Why was I able to submit the app on the Google Play Store? I understand that there are different rules for different platforms, but being a Copycat seems like a rather broad concept that both platforms would have. And how would I be eligible to use the Team Fortress 2 content on the App Store? Do I need to contact the developers of the game to get a license, etc. I will not link Concept.TF because I am not trying to promote the app, but if you go to the Google Play Store and search for it by name, it will be the first result.
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
511
Activity
Mar ’22
My first App Rejected. Copycat??
Trying to submit my first app to Apple but they won't accept it. Under the term 4.1.1 Copycat. Saying I don't have the rights or need to give proof I have the rights to use. I asked if this was good enough: section 107 of U.S. Copyright Act under the Fair Use and clearly state the intended purpose of the app is as a Parody or Satire of the third party content. They respond with ask forum and read the apple review guide which actually echoes what I said: Section 1 Safety 1.1.1. Professional political satirists and humorists are generally exempt from this requirement. But that is in regards to: harm, tasteful choices, and etc. To make things even odder. Google already accepted and published my app. https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.crystalmagic.starshiplauncher Can someone please clear up the confusion? :)
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
287
Activity
Mar ’25
Rejected for Guideline 4.1(c) Copycats
Hello everyone, I’m looking for some clarification and advice regarding an unexpected App Review rejection under Guideline 4.1 – Copycats. My app has been live on the App Store since May 2024, and during that time, it has maintained the same core flow, structure, UI, and feature set. There have been no major redesigns or attempts to imitate any other app. Recently, I submitted a new version (v3.2) with only minor changes related to ad logic implementation (no UI/UX changes, no branding changes, no metadata changes). However, this update was rejected with the following reason: “This app or its metadata appears to be misrepresenting itself as another popular app or game…” This has left me quite confused for a few reasons: The app has been approved and publicly available for nearly 2 years There were no significant design or branding changes in this submission The rejection seems unrelated to the actual changes made in this version My questions: Has anyone experienced a situation where an app was flagge
Replies
2
Boosts
0
Views
313
Activity
Mar ’26
CopyCat Rejection - what documents are required to verify that the app is mine?
Hello. I've tried a dozen times to upload my app, each time getting a response that the app was rejected due to 4.1 copycats. The most recent response: Guideline 4.1 - Design - Copycats. This app or its metadata appears to be misrepresenting itself as another popular app or game already available on the App Store, from a developer's website or distribution source, or from a third-party platform. On my requests to clarify what exactly was identified as copycats, no specifics were given to me. Because of this I conclude that it is not about some stock images or sound assets, but that it is specifically about my application (name and icon). I am the solo developer of the app and it has been available for 5 years on Google Play. No other platforms have my app on them, only Google Play. Since Apple has not provided me with specifics about what they need as proof of rights to the app, I have screen recorded my personal Google Play Developer Console account, which proves that I have all th
Replies
3
Boosts
0
Views
2.2k
Activity
Apr ’24
Please help me to understand the situation on Copycats problem of app
Hello, Our application has been rejected for many time now, and the reason is Design - Copycats. Well we spent so many time to create this app and now can't publish it. So can you please help to resolve this issue, what can be the problem? and how to resolve it? I don't know if it's our assets or anything.Thanks in advance. The review response is same all the time as follow;----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Guideline 4.1 - Design - CopycatsThis app or its metadata appears to be attempting to misrepresent itself as another popular app or game already available on the App Store or a third-party platform.Apps submitted to the App Store should be unique and should not attempt to d
Replies
5
Boosts
0
Views
3.1k
Activity
Feb ’19
4.1.0 Design: Copycats
For several months now, I have been trying to publish my app in the store, but I keep encountering the same copycat error. Since I started, I have modified absolutely everything in the game, yet I am consistently rejected without any explanation, even when I send messages. It is very frustrating to keep improving my game and always face the same situation. Could you help me and at least tell me what changes or improvements I need to make? Changes in My Game Licenses and Templates: Gunny Rush uses templates with all the necessary licenses. Unique Characters: We have five unique characters, animated from scratch by our team. Character Verification: We have implemented a verification system that allows users to use characters they own in their wallets within the game. Point Multiplier System: The more Inugis (characters) players have in the game, the higher the multiplier, and the more points they will earn per game. Dynamic Levels: Levels update dynamically as the player progresses through the game. Cu
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
445
Activity
Aug ’24
iOS App Store app copycats during delayed release/beta testing
I have an app approved by Apple waiting to be released while I collect more advance users through my landing page. I am worried about someone making a copycat app with the exact name and getting approved by Apple. For example, let's say my app is named Liquid - Dynamic Workout (the real name is slightly more unique). Could someone release an app before my set release date that is a copycat titled Liquid Workout? Additionally, for example, the domain liquidworkout.com is being squatted on, so I had to register liquidworkouts.com.Basically, if my app is already approved by Apple for app store release, and is on TestFlight, can someone still submit an app with a similar name, similar logo, and the same function? Do the copycat guidelines still apply? https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/#copycatsP.S. My app is based around a singular, unique function. I've looked through tens, maybe hundreds, of related apps.
Replies
2
Boosts
0
Views
1.8k
Activity
Jan ’18
4.1 Copycat when use content from an API
Hi,I've build an app who uses content from Wikia Fandom API.The app display characters and episodes from Rick and Morty.Of course I do not own the rights from Rick and Morty characters, but I can have the rights to use content who comes from Wikia API.My App is free of charge and do note make any money of it.How can my app be rejected for copycat reason ?It's like IMDB was rejected because it's displaying movie poster and don't own the right of the show ?Here the content of the rejection reason :Your app or its metadata appears to contain misleading content.Specifically, your app includes content that resembles “Rick and Morty” without the necessary authorization. It would be appropriate to remove all resembling content from the metadata.What do you think about it ? How can can I change that ?To be clear, my app screenshots, are in app screenshot displaying Rick and Morty characters.
Replies
2
Boosts
0
Views
747
Activity
Oct ’17