Search results for

“copycat”

146 results found

Post

Replies

Boosts

Views

Activity

How do I provide developer documentation (4.1 - Copycats)
My application does not compete with the developer. It’s an extension which sits on top of their website. Its only use is to work with their website. Without using their name, the extension does not make any sense. The developer not only has no issue with it - some of their own employees use the extension. To get documentation from developer, that’s easy. However, two questions: Developer wants to know what needs to be provided? An email, A statement? How / what format would be required they are asking? How does such above documentation get submitted / included in subsequent updates to Not hinder approval? The app went through 8 positive reviews / approvals and then all of a sudden this happened out of no where. So not understanding what changed on Apples side and how/what is sufficient documentation (email, statement, PDF, ????) from developer? thanks.
2
0
256
Dec ’25
Reply to Rejected under 4.1 (Copycats/Wordle) despite different gameplay - looking for more specific feedback
I have had close to 10 back-and forth messages with Apple review, trying to ask which parts are the issue (or whether it's the whole concept of the game) They won't tell you how you should make changes so that the game will be admitted into the store. For reference, the same app was recently approved and published on Google Play without any copycat concerns. Why is that important? Is Apple's App Store run or supervised by Google? So you started out by including 'Wordle' as one of the keywords, right? If that's the case, then it's already in the file no matter how you deny your game's association with Wordle. It seems that your only option is nuclear. Bomb and destroy it. And start over from scratch with your own ideas like creating an adventure game to search for secret words. So Changed the letter elements to be different from Wordle (circles, not squares) is not going help AT ALL. A copycat is a copycat, whether you change colors or physical forms.
3w
Rejected because app name is copycat
But which app i am copying, I don't know. I got this message: Your app or its metadata appears to contain misleading content. Specifically, your app’s name is leveraging another popular app on App Store.I did a search of my app name on the App Store and didn't find any popular app with a similar name. My app name is Decision Coin - Flip or Spin Random Choice Maker. If anyone can tell me wich app i am copying, let me know. I replied asking the reviewer this but no reply yet. Thank you so much.
1
0
1.2k
Apr ’17
App 4.1 Design: Copycats (Game)
Resolution CenterMessageHello,Thank you for providing additional information.Regarding 4.1, we continue to find your app is closely resembling Dead Space. While we under stand your app is implementing different UI, story and character, it is not appropriate for apps to leverage any copyrighted properties.You may attach documentary evidence in the App Review Information section in App Store Connect. In accordance with section 3.2(f) of the Apple Developer Program License Agreement, you acknowledge that submitting falsified or fraudulent documentation can result in the termination of your Apple Developer Program account and the removal of your apps from the App Store. Once Legal has reviewed your documentation and confirms its validity, we will proceed with the review of your app.Best regards,App Store Review////////////////////////////////////I already got reject for 2 times. and already submit an appeal for 2 weeks+.I do understand what reviewer want but the problem is I create my own model & story &
2
0
1.7k
Aug ’18
Reply to Worldcup 2018 App rejected by Apple
They refer to this guideline5.2.1 Generally: Don’t use protected third party material such as trademarks, copyrighted works, or patented ideas in your app without permission, and don’t include misleading, false, or copycat representations, names, or metadata in your app bundle or developer name. Apps should be submitted by the person or legal entity that owns or has licensed the intellectual property and other relevant rights and is responsible for offering any services provided by the app.You should go to fifa site and see what resembles your app. May be the set up to present the result trees (copycat representation) ? Or the names along the countries flags.
Aug ’18
Reply to Our application got rejected due to Guideline 4.1 - Design - Copycats
We got to have a small meeting with the App review's supporter, and she said we have two choices to grant verification on the app : We need to change the account name under the studio or the game we work on, which sometimes takes to verify the account until we can transfer the project. I need to submit documents that clarify that I am one of the development team members working on the game. So I added documents to clarify myself since we have lost almost a month in this copycats progress. After submitting every as like App reviewer suggested us in the meeting; it turns out we are still getting rejection under Copycats again. Is that any ways I can contact Apple faster than just make appointment for interview everytime to get clear answer?
Dec ’24
Reply to Review Process for Search Ads
Thanks for your reply.There is an Introducing Search Ads session tomorrow. We should get more information about how they really work.However, so far in the first beta, search ads are much worse than I could have imagined. They are completely irrelevant most of the time and favor copycat or competitor apps over genuine ones:- searching for hotel or restaurant shows you... game ads 😐- searching for famous trademarked names like twitter or snapshat shows you... competitor ads 😮- searching for specific app name like monument valley shows you... a copycat app ad 😠I really hope this will be fixed soon, as this is bad both for developers and customers (and eventually Apple itself).
Topic: App & System Services SubTopic: General Tags:
Jun ’16
CopyCat Rejection - What documentation is needed to prove the app is mine?
I have submitted my app twice, with specific documentation showcasing the termination of agreement of the original release of my game via a publisher two years ago. The original released was removed from the App Store over a year ago and the publishers App Dev account closed. I have now finally readied my game to be published by myself on the App store but keep getting rejected with this info: Your app's metadata contains content that is similar to third-party content, which may create a misleading association with another developer's app or intellectual property. Specifically, the app's description, name, and icons includes references to xxxxxx. Next Steps It would be appropriate to revise the app and metadata to remove this third-party content before resubmitting for review. If you have the necessary rights to distribute an app with this third-party content, attach documentary evidence in the App Review Information section in App Store Connect and reply to this message. ______ The App is built from MY Unity
0
0
568
Apr ’24
App rejected Guideline 4.1 Design Copycats
Dear all, I have been working for a year and invested a lot of money for creating a kind of a fantasy league related to football. I checked with a lawyer before starting the App development and he told me that if the game is free there shouldn't be any problem with the football team licenses, specially if we republish sports results (already published in all the international media). Obviously we use real football team shields, as we comply both conditions (free App and republish sports results).I have also checked other Apps in App Store and there are a lot of Apps including the same shields that I'm being told to remove from my App. I don't think all of them have any license from the FIFA or UEFA or any particular team.This is the answer I received from Apple:Guideline 4.1 - Design - CopycatsYour app or its metadata appears to contain misleading content.Specifically, your app includes content that resembles one or multiple third-party sport teams and/or leagues.It's a Freemium app, where we publish real res
1
0
2.7k
Jul ’19
“Backrooms: Escape” Removed for Alleged Copycat Months After Release (Guideline 4.1) – Advice Needed
Hello everyone, We initially published our game, Backrooms: Escape, on the App Store on October 15, 2024, and have since released 152 builds with updates. In total, our team has spent over a year working on this project. However, we recently received a notification from the App Review Team stating that our app violates Guideline 4.1 (Copycats). The explanation we received was that we use “Backrooms” as a theme. We are the legitimate rights holders of this project, which we can easily prove through both our development timeline and legal documentation. After multiple attempts to clarify the issue, the only feedback we got was that “using Backrooms” is the problem. Yet, there are well over a hundred other “Backrooms” apps currently on the App Store. Here are ten examples: Hide in The Backroom: Nextbots Noclip : Backrooms Multiplayer Backrooms Union Multiplayer Backrooms Descent: Horror Game Escape - Backrooms Horror Backrooms Anomaly Backrooms: Lost in Level 0 Backrooms: Outrun To Survive! Backrooms Bu
4
0
459
Feb ’25
Submission Issue: Guideline 4.1 - Design - Copycats
Hello, In my application I am using OpenAI's API to fetch responses inside my application. When I submit apple review they only give me this information for what is wrong with the application. Your metadata appears to contain third party content. Specifically, the app leverages OpenAI. The next submission of this app may require a longer review time. So, I would assume from this response I would not need to submit anything else. I have resubmitted and they gave me the same response. I have asked them what else I would need to add to the application, but they respond with: We are not able to provide feedback on app concepts or features, but we recommend evaluating your app against the App Store Review Guidelines, as well as the iOS Developer Program License Agreement (PLA), and the Human Interface Guidelines. I am going to try asking for more guidance for what extra I need to submit. But has anyone received issues with using API's? and how did you resolve this issue in App Store Review? Thanks in advance, Chri
1
0
901
Jan ’23
How do I provide developer documentation (4.1 - Copycats)
My application does not compete with the developer. It’s an extension which sits on top of their website. Its only use is to work with their website. Without using their name, the extension does not make any sense. The developer not only has no issue with it - some of their own employees use the extension. To get documentation from developer, that’s easy. However, two questions: Developer wants to know what needs to be provided? An email, A statement? How / what format would be required they are asking? How does such above documentation get submitted / included in subsequent updates to Not hinder approval? The app went through 8 positive reviews / approvals and then all of a sudden this happened out of no where. So not understanding what changed on Apples side and how/what is sufficient documentation (email, statement, PDF, ????) from developer? thanks.
Replies
2
Boosts
0
Views
256
Activity
Dec ’25
Reply to Rejected under 4.1 (Copycats/Wordle) despite different gameplay - looking for more specific feedback
I have had close to 10 back-and forth messages with Apple review, trying to ask which parts are the issue (or whether it's the whole concept of the game) They won't tell you how you should make changes so that the game will be admitted into the store. For reference, the same app was recently approved and published on Google Play without any copycat concerns. Why is that important? Is Apple's App Store run or supervised by Google? So you started out by including 'Wordle' as one of the keywords, right? If that's the case, then it's already in the file no matter how you deny your game's association with Wordle. It seems that your only option is nuclear. Bomb and destroy it. And start over from scratch with your own ideas like creating an adventure game to search for secret words. So Changed the letter elements to be different from Wordle (circles, not squares) is not going help AT ALL. A copycat is a copycat, whether you change colors or physical forms.
Replies
Boosts
Views
Activity
3w
Rejected because app name is copycat
But which app i am copying, I don't know. I got this message: Your app or its metadata appears to contain misleading content. Specifically, your app’s name is leveraging another popular app on App Store.I did a search of my app name on the App Store and didn't find any popular app with a similar name. My app name is Decision Coin - Flip or Spin Random Choice Maker. If anyone can tell me wich app i am copying, let me know. I replied asking the reviewer this but no reply yet. Thank you so much.
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
1.2k
Activity
Apr ’17
App 4.1 Design: Copycats (Game)
Resolution CenterMessageHello,Thank you for providing additional information.Regarding 4.1, we continue to find your app is closely resembling Dead Space. While we under stand your app is implementing different UI, story and character, it is not appropriate for apps to leverage any copyrighted properties.You may attach documentary evidence in the App Review Information section in App Store Connect. In accordance with section 3.2(f) of the Apple Developer Program License Agreement, you acknowledge that submitting falsified or fraudulent documentation can result in the termination of your Apple Developer Program account and the removal of your apps from the App Store. Once Legal has reviewed your documentation and confirms its validity, we will proceed with the review of your app.Best regards,App Store Review////////////////////////////////////I already got reject for 2 times. and already submit an appeal for 2 weeks+.I do understand what reviewer want but the problem is I create my own model & story &
Replies
2
Boosts
0
Views
1.7k
Activity
Aug ’18
Reply to Please help me to understand the situation on Copycats problem of app
How is anyone supposed to answer you? We don't know who you are and what your app does. No one has seen it other than Apple App Review. Those people see all apps and should be very skilled at identifying copycat apps. Why should we doubt their judgement?
Replies
Boosts
Views
Activity
Feb ’19
Reply to Worldcup 2018 App rejected by Apple
They refer to this guideline5.2.1 Generally: Don’t use protected third party material such as trademarks, copyrighted works, or patented ideas in your app without permission, and don’t include misleading, false, or copycat representations, names, or metadata in your app bundle or developer name. Apps should be submitted by the person or legal entity that owns or has licensed the intellectual property and other relevant rights and is responsible for offering any services provided by the app.You should go to fifa site and see what resembles your app. May be the set up to present the result trees (copycat representation) ? Or the names along the countries flags.
Replies
Boosts
Views
Activity
Aug ’18
Reply to Copycats ? but i have permission from the representative?
Hello utopie, I am just facing the same issue. I have developed an app for a popular political german news blog. I have their explicit permission to develop it and take their icons and so on for it. I was also rejected with the reference to Guideline 4.1 Copycats. Were you able to solve the problem? Thank you in advamce!
Replies
Boosts
Views
Activity
Apr ’21
Reply to Repeated Rejections Under Guideline 4.1 “Copycats” – No Specific Feedback from App Review
Thank you for your post. There are several factors that may contribute to an app not following App Review Guideline 4.1. Visit Preventing Copycat and Impersonation Rejections to learn best practices that will help you submit original apps that follow this guideline.
Replies
Boosts
Views
Activity
Jul ’25
Reply to Our application got rejected due to Guideline 4.1 - Design - Copycats
We got to have a small meeting with the App review's supporter, and she said we have two choices to grant verification on the app : We need to change the account name under the studio or the game we work on, which sometimes takes to verify the account until we can transfer the project. I need to submit documents that clarify that I am one of the development team members working on the game. So I added documents to clarify myself since we have lost almost a month in this copycats progress. After submitting every as like App reviewer suggested us in the meeting; it turns out we are still getting rejection under Copycats again. Is that any ways I can contact Apple faster than just make appointment for interview everytime to get clear answer?
Replies
Boosts
Views
Activity
Dec ’24
Reply to Review Process for Search Ads
Thanks for your reply.There is an Introducing Search Ads session tomorrow. We should get more information about how they really work.However, so far in the first beta, search ads are much worse than I could have imagined. They are completely irrelevant most of the time and favor copycat or competitor apps over genuine ones:- searching for hotel or restaurant shows you... game ads 😐- searching for famous trademarked names like twitter or snapshat shows you... competitor ads 😮- searching for specific app name like monument valley shows you... a copycat app ad 😠I really hope this will be fixed soon, as this is bad both for developers and customers (and eventually Apple itself).
Topic: App & System Services SubTopic: General Tags:
Replies
Boosts
Views
Activity
Jun ’16
CopyCat Rejection - What documentation is needed to prove the app is mine?
I have submitted my app twice, with specific documentation showcasing the termination of agreement of the original release of my game via a publisher two years ago. The original released was removed from the App Store over a year ago and the publishers App Dev account closed. I have now finally readied my game to be published by myself on the App store but keep getting rejected with this info: Your app's metadata contains content that is similar to third-party content, which may create a misleading association with another developer's app or intellectual property. Specifically, the app's description, name, and icons includes references to xxxxxx. Next Steps It would be appropriate to revise the app and metadata to remove this third-party content before resubmitting for review. If you have the necessary rights to distribute an app with this third-party content, attach documentary evidence in the App Review Information section in App Store Connect and reply to this message. ______ The App is built from MY Unity
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
568
Activity
Apr ’24
App rejected Guideline 4.1 Design Copycats
Dear all, I have been working for a year and invested a lot of money for creating a kind of a fantasy league related to football. I checked with a lawyer before starting the App development and he told me that if the game is free there shouldn't be any problem with the football team licenses, specially if we republish sports results (already published in all the international media). Obviously we use real football team shields, as we comply both conditions (free App and republish sports results).I have also checked other Apps in App Store and there are a lot of Apps including the same shields that I'm being told to remove from my App. I don't think all of them have any license from the FIFA or UEFA or any particular team.This is the answer I received from Apple:Guideline 4.1 - Design - CopycatsYour app or its metadata appears to contain misleading content.Specifically, your app includes content that resembles one or multiple third-party sport teams and/or leagues.It's a Freemium app, where we publish real res
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
2.7k
Activity
Jul ’19
“Backrooms: Escape” Removed for Alleged Copycat Months After Release (Guideline 4.1) – Advice Needed
Hello everyone, We initially published our game, Backrooms: Escape, on the App Store on October 15, 2024, and have since released 152 builds with updates. In total, our team has spent over a year working on this project. However, we recently received a notification from the App Review Team stating that our app violates Guideline 4.1 (Copycats). The explanation we received was that we use “Backrooms” as a theme. We are the legitimate rights holders of this project, which we can easily prove through both our development timeline and legal documentation. After multiple attempts to clarify the issue, the only feedback we got was that “using Backrooms” is the problem. Yet, there are well over a hundred other “Backrooms” apps currently on the App Store. Here are ten examples: Hide in The Backroom: Nextbots Noclip : Backrooms Multiplayer Backrooms Union Multiplayer Backrooms Descent: Horror Game Escape - Backrooms Horror Backrooms Anomaly Backrooms: Lost in Level 0 Backrooms: Outrun To Survive! Backrooms Bu
Replies
4
Boosts
0
Views
459
Activity
Feb ’25
Submission Issue: Guideline 4.1 - Design - Copycats
Hello, In my application I am using OpenAI's API to fetch responses inside my application. When I submit apple review they only give me this information for what is wrong with the application. Your metadata appears to contain third party content. Specifically, the app leverages OpenAI. The next submission of this app may require a longer review time. So, I would assume from this response I would not need to submit anything else. I have resubmitted and they gave me the same response. I have asked them what else I would need to add to the application, but they respond with: We are not able to provide feedback on app concepts or features, but we recommend evaluating your app against the App Store Review Guidelines, as well as the iOS Developer Program License Agreement (PLA), and the Human Interface Guidelines. I am going to try asking for more guidance for what extra I need to submit. But has anyone received issues with using API's? and how did you resolve this issue in App Store Review? Thanks in advance, Chri
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
901
Activity
Jan ’23
Reply to Avoiding Rejection for CopyCat
Thank you for your post. There are several factors that may contribute to an app not following App Review Guideline 4.1. Visit Preventing Copycat and Impersonation Rejections to learn best practices that will help you submit original apps that follow this guideline.
Replies
Boosts
Views
Activity
Jan ’26