Apple Developers

RSS for tag

This is a dedicated space for developers to connect, share ideas, collaborate, and ask questions. Introduce yourself, network with other developers, and foster a supportive community.

Learn More

Posts under Apple Developers subtopic

Post

Replies

Boosts

Views

Activity

[P1 – CRITICAL PRIVACY/SECURITY] iOS Messages “Delete and Stop” Can Validate Active Phone Numbers — Urgent Mitigation Required
Post: P1 / SEV-1 — URGENT SECURITY AND PRIVACY DESIGN ISSUE iOS Messages contains a potentially dangerous behavior in its “Stop or Report Spam” → “Delete and Stop” workflow: selecting this option sends an outbound STOP message to the sender. This creates a serious phone-number enumeration and validation risk. The threat is not limited to conventional scams. Some spam operators are not initially trying to defraud the recipient. Their objective is simply to determine whether a telephone number is active, monitored, and associated with a real person. Any response—including STOP—can provide that confirmation. Validated numbers can then be retained, sold, shared, or targeted with additional spam, phishing attempts, and fraudulent campaigns. This is particularly concerning because users may believe they are simply reporting and deleting unwanted messages. Instead, the operating system can initiate an outbound communication with the very sender they are attempting to avoid. Security concerns: - An unsolicited outbound response can confirm that a number is active and monitored. - Users may trigger this behavior without understanding its security implications. - Reporting spam should not require communicating with the suspected spammer. - The reporting workflow should not override an existing block or otherwise initiate contact with a blocked sender. - Blocking may be bypassed: Even when the sender has already been blocked, selecting “Delete and Stop” will override the block and still transmit an outbound STOP message to that sender. This appears to undermine the user's explicit decision to prevent further contact and potentially re-establish communication with a blocked number. Expected behavior: Reporting and deleting suspected spam should be entirely passive. Apple should not transmit any message to the sender as part of that process without explicit, informed consent. Requested action: 1. Immediately disable “Delete and Stop” as a temporary mitigation pending security and privacy review. 2. Escalate this issue to the iOS Messages engineering and Product Security teams. 3. Review the outbound-message behavior, including interactions with blocked senders. 4. Separate spam reporting, deletion, blocking, and subscription cancellation into distinct actions. This is not merely a UI concern. It is a potentially systemic privacy vulnerability in a core operating-system messaging workflow, exposing users to further targeting precisely when they are attempting to protect themselves. 5. Investigate why the “Delete and Stop” workflow can transmit a message to a sender who is already blocked, and ensure that no spam-reporting action can override an existing block. Requesting urgent engineering review and confirmation that this has been escalated. See both screenshots attached. Thanks
0
0
101
1d
Apple Developer Account Terminated After 10+ Years - Looking for Guidance
I’ve been publishing apps and games on Apple’s platform for over 10 years, and it’s heartbreaking to think that a decade of hard work, countless sleepless nights, and dreams could come to an end like this. Three weeks ago, our Apple Developer account was terminated. Throughout these years, I’ve always tried my best to follow Apple’s guidelines. I have never intentionally violated any rules, nor would I ever want to. Whenever the App Review team identified an issue, I worked with them to understand it, make the necessary changes, and ensure our games met Apple’s requirements. For the past three weeks, I’ve spent countless hours trying to understand what might have led to this decision and what I could have done differently. I want to share a few things I’ve been reflecting on, not because I know they caused the termination, but because I genuinely want to understand and improve. Contacting Apple Support About a Delayed Review About a week before the termination, I contacted Apple Developer Support to ask about a game that had been in the “In Review” state for over three weeks. Our games typically complete the review process within two or three days, so I was concerned there might be a technical issue. My intention was never to pressure the review team or ask them to speed up the process. I simply wanted to understand whether something was wrong. I fully respect the work Apple’s review team does and understand that reviews can take longer than expected. Our Game “Needle in a Haystack” We developed a game called Needle in a Haystack, inspired by an idea we came across on social media. We later learned that other games with a similar concept or name existed on platforms such as Steam and Roblox. Our game was developed independently, with its own gameplay, interface, and design. We never intended to copy another developer’s work or misrepresent our game as someone else’s. If you check the publication dates, you’ll see that our game was published several days earlier. Once we became aware of the naming overlap, we changed the name. Unused App Listings Over the years, we’ve created App Store Connect listings for game ideas that we eventually decided not to pursue. I didn’t realise that keeping unused listings might potentially raise concerns. As part of reviewing our account, I’ve recently removed these abandoned listings. If this practice created any issues, I would be happy to understand the relevant guidelines and make sure it doesn’t happen again. In-App Purchases and Refunds Some of our games offer higher-priced in-app purchases, including items priced around $100. We’ve noticed situations where purchases were refunded after the content had been used. I understand that purchase handling, refund processing, and customer experience are important responsibilities for developers. If our implementation needs improvement, we’re fully prepared to review it and make any necessary changes to ensure everything works correctly and complies with Apple’s policies. App Review Access to Game Features Recently, the App Review team requested access to an administrative panel associated with one of our games. That functionality was not immediately accessible because it was tied to a gameplay feature that unlocks at level 4 during the game’s nighttime cycle. As soon as the team requested access, we provided the necessary information. Looking back, we could have made these testing requirements clearer in our review notes from the beginning. We’ll make sure future submissions include better instructions and access to features that require specific gameplay conditions. These past three weeks have been incredibly difficult for me and my team. Building games has been more than a business for me. It’s something I’ve dedicated over a decade of my life to. Every release represents months of work, late nights, challenges, and the excitement of creating something that people around the world can enjoy. I understand that Apple has rules for a reason, and I respect the importance of protecting the App Store and its users. I’m not asking for special treatment or an exception to the rules. I’m simply hoping for an opportunity to understand what went wrong, address any concerns, and demonstrate that we’re committed to being responsible developers. If we made mistakes, we want to learn from them. If something needs to be changed, we’re ready to change it. The thought of losing everything we’ve built over the past 10 years, without fully understanding why, is devastating. I sincerely hope our history, our willingness to cooperate, and our commitment to doing better can be taken into consideration. If anyone from Apple or the developer community can offer guidance on the appropriate next steps, I would be deeply grateful. Thank you for taking the time to read our story.
0
0
117
1d
Instant Hotspot fails between iPhone 13 (27.0.1) and iPhone 17 Pro (27.3 beta 2)
Two iPhones signed in to the same Apple Account. Device A (hotspot provider): iPhone 17 Pro, iOS 27.3 beta 2 (24C5049d) Device B (client): iPhone 13, iOS 27.0.1 ## Summary B cannot wake A's Personal Hotspot on its own. If no other device is connected to A, tapping A's hotspot in B's Wi-Fi list fails with "Failed to enable hotspot" / "Failed to enable hotspot after 2 attempts". Once a third device (an Android tablet) connects to the same hotspot and brings it up, B connects immediately with no prompt. After that third device disconnects and the hotspot goes back to sleep, B fails again, exactly as before. The cycle repeats every time. ## Repro 1. On A, turn on Personal Hotspot. Make sure no device is connected, then wait about 90 seconds so the hotspot AP goes to sleep. 2. On B, open Settings > Wi-Fi and tap A's hotspot. 3. After a few seconds B shows "Failed to enable hotspot" / "Failed to enable hotspot after 2 attempts". 4. Tap OK and try again — same result. ## What brings it back 1. Connect an Android tablet to A's hotspot with the Wi-Fi password. It works normally and gets internet access. 2. Without disconnecting the tablet, tap A's hotspot on B again. B connects immediately, no prompt, no error. 3. Disconnect the tablet and wait for the hotspot to go back to sleep. 4. Tap the hotspot on B again — the same error returns. This is repeatable, and the result is fully determined by whether the hotspot AP is awake. ## Version comparison The same two devices worked on iOS 27.3 beta 1. B connected within 1-2 seconds with no error. A was updated to beta 2 on 2026-11-16, and the problem started right after. ## Expected B should be able to wake A's hotspot through Instant Hotspot and join it directly. ## Actual B's wake request is never honored. The hotspot only becomes joinable if something else brings the AP up first. This rules out a credential, pairing, or saved-network issue on B. The hotspot itself is healthy — the Android tablet connects and browses normally. The failing piece is the Instant Hotspot wake path in iOS 27.3 beta 2 when the peer device runs an older build. Feedback ID: FB25613861
1
0
92
1d
Battery chart time labels shifted hours ahead on macOS 27 (endOfDay wrong in BatteryUI.plist)
the "last 24 hours" battery level and screen on usage charts in system settings > battery have the hour labels shifted way ahead of real time. the bars are in the right order, the axis is just wrong. at 17:13 it was showing stuff up to like 23:00. at 10:05 a few days later it was about 12 hours ahead. the "last charged to 100%" time above the chart is correct tho. my clock and time zone are fine (asia/manila, set automatically, synced). the battery data itself is right too, i checked the power log and the plug in and unplug times match what actually happened. i dug into it and found the problem in `/private/var/db/powerlog/Library/BatteryLife/Debug/BatteryUI.plist`, which is what the battery pane gets from PerfPowerServices. `endOfDay` comes back as the next hour instead of midnight: PLBatteryUIQueryTime 2026-10-24 17:13:25 (local) endOfHour 2026-10-24 18:00:00 <- correct endOfDay 2026-10-24 18:00:00 <- should be 2026-10-25 00:00:00 so the chart puts 00:00 at 18:00 yesterday and everything ends up 6 hours off. it looks like the chart always labels its right edge as 24:00, so the further you are from midnight the worse it gets. restarting PerfPowerServices (`sudo killall PerfPowerServices`) doesn't fix it, the new process sends the same values right away. macos 27.0.1 (26A434). this was fine on macos 26. looks like the same bug as https://developer.apple.com/forums/thread/852392
0
0
119
2d
Account pending
Hi everyone, I purchased an Apple Developer Program membership about three days ago. The payment has already been successfully charged to my bank account, but my account is still showing the status “Pending” with the message “Subscribe your membership.” I haven’t received any confirmation email or any request for additional information since completing the purchase. I’m curious if others have experienced a similar delay recently, and how long it took before your developer account was fully activated. Any insights or experiences would be greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance!
20
7
4.3k
2d
Blocked in Public Beta?
I am wondering. For several OS versions, I have been unable to sign in to the public beta. Has anyone else experienced this? I attempted to work with support, but it does not appear they understand what is going on, or... You see, when I have been evaluating Apple products and services (I had beta tested for so many releases), I was quite detailed in business concepts, ideas of the culture, and the impacts that the organization has and outcomes that may come from their culture. Well, I was not intending to actually send those because they were only for me and like a journal for me to reference aspects like emotions, psychosis -how different activities and experiences impacted different lenses (empathy), and some of the dynamic evaluated actions like a game of chess. Well, I accidentally sent them. I'm sure it terrified whoever read it. Apple has not been very honest with me; no emails were received outlining concerns about the content. However, my account has been unable to access Beta now for quite some time. I don't even remember when it stopped. I have tried to unenroll (but it won't allow me to), I have tried to reenroll, etc. I have cleared the cache, I have deleted profiles, and removed anything that could interfere, but it does not seem to want to connect. The only thing I can think of is that maybe there is a clash between a developer profile and a public beta profile? Perhaps I am somehow enrolled as a developer? I have not built out any apps or anything like that. Also, I have never made any money from my feedback. Though I should. I am very good at identifying operational gaps between end-user connectivity and actual usage. Organic growth is a good sign of a good quality product. Nonetheless, for the longest time, I did not have the money, nor really the professional need to pay for the developer program. I'm just curious if anyone else out there is encountering similar issues.
0
0
141
2d
Account
Hi Community! I'm having an issue with the enrolment process, which seems to be stuck "In review" for 3 weeks now. The current status: Your documentation is in review. We received your documents and are processing your enrollment.The timeline: Oct 12: Enrolment signed and received Oct 21: I received a request to send additional documents - which were sent on that exact day. Oct 30: I requested a status update - no reply since then (retried on Nov 9, Nov 10 and today). Is anyone else experiencing a similar situation? Wanted to make sure that my request didn't fall into the void :p Thanks!
1
0
169
2d
Apple Developer enrollment paid, but account now shows “Not Eligible”
Title: Apple Developer enrollment paid, but account now shows “Not Eligible” Hello, I recently enrolled in the Apple Developer Program using my Apple Account. I completed the enrollment process and paid the membership fee using Apple Pay. The payment was successfully charged, and during the enrollment process I was told that I would receive an email shortly regarding the enrollment. However, I never received that email. When I now log in to my Apple Developer account, it says that my account is not eligible for the Apple Developer Program. The membership fee has already been charged, so I would like to understand what happened to my enrollment and whether the payment can be associated with my application. Could someone please advise me on what I should do next or how I can have the enrollment and payment reviewed? Thank you.
10
2
1.2k
2d
Problems uploading screenshots for more than a day
Hello! I am preparing a couple of apps for approval, and suddenly can not upload screenshots to the app store. When I drag and drop into the interface, it accepts them, shows that they are being processed, and after a minute or so, says that there is a problem, and to try again later. It's been doing this for more than a day. Has anyone else seen this? Dave
0
0
239
4d
Individual enrollment – wrong address is locked on my pending enrollment, can't edit it
Hi, I'm enrolling in the Apple Developer Program as an individual. I made a mistake in my address during enrollment. I tried to start the enrollment again with the same Apple Account, but it brings back the same wrong address and I can't edit it. The Membership details section doesn't appear in my account because the enrollment is still pending. Type: Individual Payment: paid on November 8th 2026 ID verification: not uploaded yet Could someone from Apple please: Correct the address on my enrollment, or reset it so I can enter the right address myself? Cancel any duplicate enrollment, so only one remains? I'm happy to provide proof of address. I haven't uploaded my ID or continued, because I don't want the wrong address verified. Thank you!
0
0
213
4d
What does this mean
I recently paid for my Apple developer on Apple approve it for few minutes later I get this message from Apple " We're having a problem with your payment. Order Number: D005486847 Ordered On November 13, 2026 To avoid a delay in receiving your order, contact us via the Developer page to change your payment information. You may contact your card provider to find more information. If after 7 days we're still unable to process your payment, your order will be canceled. If you have any questions, contact us at devpayment@apple.com. For your protection, do not submit credit card information via email or form. " I can help, but feel it will be all successful. what should i do?
0
0
71
5d
Enrollment paid over 48 hours ago — membership still inactive
Hello Apple Developer Support, I purchased the Apple Developer Program membership two days ago, and my order is confirmed in the Apple Store - Order Number W1814011542 | Ordered on November 07, 2026. However, my Apple Developer account still prompts me to purchase the membership and says to allow 48 hours for processing. More than 48 hours have now passed, and my membership remains inactive. I have also submitted a support request, but the issue is still unresolved. Could you please check my payment and enrollment status, confirm whether any further action is required from me, and let me know when my membership will be activated? Is it normal for activation to take longer than 48 hours? My previous support case ID is 30000009068984. Thank you for your assistance.
6
1
238
5d
macOS 27 – Minimized windows at the bottom of the screen missing when showing application windows
Right/Control-clicking an app in the Dock and doing ”Show All Windows” used to show any minimized windows for that app at the bottom of the screen. Since macOS 27 they don't show up there anymore. In macOS 26 they do. Why was this feature removed? I hope it wasn't intentional as it is quite handy to see the minimized windows there and being able to navigate to them from the keyboard (arrows). Which takes me to the the Mission Control feature that is showing all app windows – why won't pressing tab in that view do anything? I think a tab press should move focus to the frontmost window in the next app in this view. Also, maybe it would be good to as an option show the app icon of the app one is switching to when pressing tab after Mission Control for the current app windows are in view. Now it switches to the next app's windows, but it can take some time to get to terms with which app's windows I'm actually looking at. I think showing the app icon quicky (or persinstantly somewhere) would help the user understanding what app's windows are being looked at more quickly. Some more love for Mission Control, please! :)
0
0
66
5d
Home content caching with an intermittently available MacBook — options for an older Mac mini or another device?
Hello everyone, I am looking for technical guidance on maintaining a content cache for private use on my home network. I currently use my MacBook to handle the registration of a cache running on a Linux/Docker server. The MacBook is a regularly used laptop, so it is not always awake or connected to my home network. I would like to understand whether an older Mac mini or another device could take over this role reliably. For cost reasons, I would prefer not to purchase a Mac mini M1 or newer solely for this purpose. The implementation I am experimenting with is Maurice’s Open Apple Cache project. It handles the actual caching on Linux and uses a small macOS helper to register the cache with Apple. I understand that this is an experimental third-party project using private macOS interfaces, rather than an Apple-supported implementation. To clarify, I understand that the Docker-based setup is not Apple’s preferred or officially supported approach. My preferred solution would actually be to use an older Mac as a dedicated, always-on content cache, ideally running Apple’s built-in Content Caching service. The Linux/Docker setup is an experiment rather than a requirement. I would therefore particularly welcome guidance on whether an older Intel Mac could still provide a reliable solution for a household with current Apple devices, and which hardware and macOS requirements I should consider. The recurring problem is that the cache becomes undiscoverable while the MacBook is asleep or unavailable. The Linux service continues running, its health checks remain successful, and a direct download test still produces a cache HIT. However, Apple devices no longer discover it automatically. For example, AssetCacheLocatorUtil returned the following on the MacBook after the problem occurred: --- Information for system services: Checking whether there might be content caches available... There might be content caches available. Finding refreshed content caches supporting shared caching... Found 0 content caches --- Information for user 502 (results for other users may be different): Finding refreshed content caches supporting shared caching... Found 0 content caches Testing all found content caches for reachability... No content caches to test.The helper’s status file still showed "state": "registered", but its last successful registration was approximately 13 hours old. After I manually ran the registration helper again, the cache became discoverable and was reported as healthy. No changes to the Docker service were necessary. The helper currently runs as a LaunchAgent and attempts registration every 3,000 seconds. Its registration response reports a heartbeat interval of 3,300 seconds. I do not know whether that interval corresponds to the actual registration lifetime, so I would appreciate clarification rather than assuming a specific expiry time. My questions are: What is Apple’s recommended approach for home content caching when no Mac is continuously available? Could an older Intel Mac mini reliably perform the registration and renewal role, even if the actual cache remains on another server? Is registration from a system LaunchDaemon, without an interactive user login, technically possible? Are there relevant restrictions involving AuthKit or the execution context? Are there public APIs, documentation, or Apple open-source components that could help implement this functionality on older hardware or another platform? Is there a supported way to maintain discovery during longer periods when the registering Mac is asleep or offline? I would also appreciate Apple’s perspective on whether a project such as Open Apple Cache is a reasonable alternative for private households without an always-on Mac, or whether a different architecture would be preferable. This is solely for sharing Apple software updates and App Store downloads among devices within my household. Thank you for any technical guidance or pointers to relevant documentation. Kind regards, Philipp
0
0
48
5d
Individual enrollment stuck for 9 days after ID verification – app says I can't continue, website asks me to pay again
Hi everyone, I enrolled in the Apple Developer Program as an individual (Argentina) on November 2 and paid the US$99 fee. The payment is confirmed. On November 3–4 I uploaded my national ID (DNI) as requested, and Apple confirmed receipt. Since then, nothing has changed: the account still isn't active and I haven't received any further emails. Right now I'm getting two contradictory messages: In the Apple Developer app, it says enrollment can't be completed from the app. On the website (https://www.google.com/url?q=http://developer.apple.com/account&source=gmail&ust=1794536143988000&sa=E), it shows "Purchase your membership", as if I hadn't paid. But the charge already went through and I have the order confirmation. I don't want to pay twice, so I haven't touched that button. What I've tried: Opened a support case (Case ID 30000004906936) and followed up by email from the case page. No reply so far. Tried to request a phone call, but it shows as unavailable due to high volume. My app is ready to submit (it's already in closed testing on Google Play), and everything on the iOS side is blocked until the membership is activated. Is this normal while the ID is under review? Is there anything else I can do, or could someone from Apple take a look at the case? Thanks!
3
1
144
5d
Digital Services Act verification delays and lack of support communication
I’m posting because several developers have reported lengthy delays with Digital Services Act trader verification, with little visibility into what is happening or when they can expect a decision. Some developers report waiting more than four weeks, others two weeks. My own verification has been pending for 10 days. Contacting support does not always help: developers describe receiving no response, or waiting another two weeks for a reply. We understand that verification takes time and that some cases require additional checks. What is frustrating is the uncertainty: no meaningful status updates, no clear indication of whether anything is missing, and no reliable timeframe. We pay an annual Apple Developer Program membership fee... that does not mean every request should receive immediate approval, but timely communication and respectful support are reasonable expectations especially when these processes affect our ability to distribute an app and plan a launch. What is the current expected timeframe for DSA trader verification...When should developers escalate a pending verification, and through which channel? How can we confirm whether our submission is complete or requires additional information? Can developers receive meaningful progress updates instead of remaining indefinitely in “Pending Review”? For developers who have recently completed this process, how long did it take, and was there a support channel that actually helped? The concern is not simply waiting. It is having no useful information or assistance while we wait.
0
0
63
5d
[P1 – CRITICAL PRIVACY/SECURITY] iOS Messages “Delete and Stop” Can Validate Active Phone Numbers — Urgent Mitigation Required
Post: P1 / SEV-1 — URGENT SECURITY AND PRIVACY DESIGN ISSUE iOS Messages contains a potentially dangerous behavior in its “Stop or Report Spam” → “Delete and Stop” workflow: selecting this option sends an outbound STOP message to the sender. This creates a serious phone-number enumeration and validation risk. The threat is not limited to conventional scams. Some spam operators are not initially trying to defraud the recipient. Their objective is simply to determine whether a telephone number is active, monitored, and associated with a real person. Any response—including STOP—can provide that confirmation. Validated numbers can then be retained, sold, shared, or targeted with additional spam, phishing attempts, and fraudulent campaigns. This is particularly concerning because users may believe they are simply reporting and deleting unwanted messages. Instead, the operating system can initiate an outbound communication with the very sender they are attempting to avoid. Security concerns: - An unsolicited outbound response can confirm that a number is active and monitored. - Users may trigger this behavior without understanding its security implications. - Reporting spam should not require communicating with the suspected spammer. - The reporting workflow should not override an existing block or otherwise initiate contact with a blocked sender. - Blocking may be bypassed: Even when the sender has already been blocked, selecting “Delete and Stop” will override the block and still transmit an outbound STOP message to that sender. This appears to undermine the user's explicit decision to prevent further contact and potentially re-establish communication with a blocked number. Expected behavior: Reporting and deleting suspected spam should be entirely passive. Apple should not transmit any message to the sender as part of that process without explicit, informed consent. Requested action: 1. Immediately disable “Delete and Stop” as a temporary mitigation pending security and privacy review. 2. Escalate this issue to the iOS Messages engineering and Product Security teams. 3. Review the outbound-message behavior, including interactions with blocked senders. 4. Separate spam reporting, deletion, blocking, and subscription cancellation into distinct actions. This is not merely a UI concern. It is a potentially systemic privacy vulnerability in a core operating-system messaging workflow, exposing users to further targeting precisely when they are attempting to protect themselves. 5. Investigate why the “Delete and Stop” workflow can transmit a message to a sender who is already blocked, and ensure that no spam-reporting action can override an existing block. Requesting urgent engineering review and confirmation that this has been escalated. See both screenshots attached. Thanks
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
101
Activity
1d
Apple Developer Account Terminated After 10+ Years - Looking for Guidance
I’ve been publishing apps and games on Apple’s platform for over 10 years, and it’s heartbreaking to think that a decade of hard work, countless sleepless nights, and dreams could come to an end like this. Three weeks ago, our Apple Developer account was terminated. Throughout these years, I’ve always tried my best to follow Apple’s guidelines. I have never intentionally violated any rules, nor would I ever want to. Whenever the App Review team identified an issue, I worked with them to understand it, make the necessary changes, and ensure our games met Apple’s requirements. For the past three weeks, I’ve spent countless hours trying to understand what might have led to this decision and what I could have done differently. I want to share a few things I’ve been reflecting on, not because I know they caused the termination, but because I genuinely want to understand and improve. Contacting Apple Support About a Delayed Review About a week before the termination, I contacted Apple Developer Support to ask about a game that had been in the “In Review” state for over three weeks. Our games typically complete the review process within two or three days, so I was concerned there might be a technical issue. My intention was never to pressure the review team or ask them to speed up the process. I simply wanted to understand whether something was wrong. I fully respect the work Apple’s review team does and understand that reviews can take longer than expected. Our Game “Needle in a Haystack” We developed a game called Needle in a Haystack, inspired by an idea we came across on social media. We later learned that other games with a similar concept or name existed on platforms such as Steam and Roblox. Our game was developed independently, with its own gameplay, interface, and design. We never intended to copy another developer’s work or misrepresent our game as someone else’s. If you check the publication dates, you’ll see that our game was published several days earlier. Once we became aware of the naming overlap, we changed the name. Unused App Listings Over the years, we’ve created App Store Connect listings for game ideas that we eventually decided not to pursue. I didn’t realise that keeping unused listings might potentially raise concerns. As part of reviewing our account, I’ve recently removed these abandoned listings. If this practice created any issues, I would be happy to understand the relevant guidelines and make sure it doesn’t happen again. In-App Purchases and Refunds Some of our games offer higher-priced in-app purchases, including items priced around $100. We’ve noticed situations where purchases were refunded after the content had been used. I understand that purchase handling, refund processing, and customer experience are important responsibilities for developers. If our implementation needs improvement, we’re fully prepared to review it and make any necessary changes to ensure everything works correctly and complies with Apple’s policies. App Review Access to Game Features Recently, the App Review team requested access to an administrative panel associated with one of our games. That functionality was not immediately accessible because it was tied to a gameplay feature that unlocks at level 4 during the game’s nighttime cycle. As soon as the team requested access, we provided the necessary information. Looking back, we could have made these testing requirements clearer in our review notes from the beginning. We’ll make sure future submissions include better instructions and access to features that require specific gameplay conditions. These past three weeks have been incredibly difficult for me and my team. Building games has been more than a business for me. It’s something I’ve dedicated over a decade of my life to. Every release represents months of work, late nights, challenges, and the excitement of creating something that people around the world can enjoy. I understand that Apple has rules for a reason, and I respect the importance of protecting the App Store and its users. I’m not asking for special treatment or an exception to the rules. I’m simply hoping for an opportunity to understand what went wrong, address any concerns, and demonstrate that we’re committed to being responsible developers. If we made mistakes, we want to learn from them. If something needs to be changed, we’re ready to change it. The thought of losing everything we’ve built over the past 10 years, without fully understanding why, is devastating. I sincerely hope our history, our willingness to cooperate, and our commitment to doing better can be taken into consideration. If anyone from Apple or the developer community can offer guidance on the appropriate next steps, I would be deeply grateful. Thank you for taking the time to read our story.
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
117
Activity
1d
How can I delete this?
I have already left the beta program, but I am still unable to leave the developer account. As shown in the attached screenshot, it is still listed. How can I remove myself from it?
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
71
Activity
1d
Instant Hotspot fails between iPhone 13 (27.0.1) and iPhone 17 Pro (27.3 beta 2)
Two iPhones signed in to the same Apple Account. Device A (hotspot provider): iPhone 17 Pro, iOS 27.3 beta 2 (24C5049d) Device B (client): iPhone 13, iOS 27.0.1 ## Summary B cannot wake A's Personal Hotspot on its own. If no other device is connected to A, tapping A's hotspot in B's Wi-Fi list fails with "Failed to enable hotspot" / "Failed to enable hotspot after 2 attempts". Once a third device (an Android tablet) connects to the same hotspot and brings it up, B connects immediately with no prompt. After that third device disconnects and the hotspot goes back to sleep, B fails again, exactly as before. The cycle repeats every time. ## Repro 1. On A, turn on Personal Hotspot. Make sure no device is connected, then wait about 90 seconds so the hotspot AP goes to sleep. 2. On B, open Settings > Wi-Fi and tap A's hotspot. 3. After a few seconds B shows "Failed to enable hotspot" / "Failed to enable hotspot after 2 attempts". 4. Tap OK and try again — same result. ## What brings it back 1. Connect an Android tablet to A's hotspot with the Wi-Fi password. It works normally and gets internet access. 2. Without disconnecting the tablet, tap A's hotspot on B again. B connects immediately, no prompt, no error. 3. Disconnect the tablet and wait for the hotspot to go back to sleep. 4. Tap the hotspot on B again — the same error returns. This is repeatable, and the result is fully determined by whether the hotspot AP is awake. ## Version comparison The same two devices worked on iOS 27.3 beta 1. B connected within 1-2 seconds with no error. A was updated to beta 2 on 2026-11-16, and the problem started right after. ## Expected B should be able to wake A's hotspot through Instant Hotspot and join it directly. ## Actual B's wake request is never honored. The hotspot only becomes joinable if something else brings the AP up first. This rules out a credential, pairing, or saved-network issue on B. The hotspot itself is healthy — the Android tablet connects and browses normally. The failing piece is the Instant Hotspot wake path in iOS 27.3 beta 2 when the peer device runs an older build. Feedback ID: FB25613861
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
92
Activity
1d
Battery chart time labels shifted hours ahead on macOS 27 (endOfDay wrong in BatteryUI.plist)
the "last 24 hours" battery level and screen on usage charts in system settings > battery have the hour labels shifted way ahead of real time. the bars are in the right order, the axis is just wrong. at 17:13 it was showing stuff up to like 23:00. at 10:05 a few days later it was about 12 hours ahead. the "last charged to 100%" time above the chart is correct tho. my clock and time zone are fine (asia/manila, set automatically, synced). the battery data itself is right too, i checked the power log and the plug in and unplug times match what actually happened. i dug into it and found the problem in `/private/var/db/powerlog/Library/BatteryLife/Debug/BatteryUI.plist`, which is what the battery pane gets from PerfPowerServices. `endOfDay` comes back as the next hour instead of midnight: PLBatteryUIQueryTime 2026-10-24 17:13:25 (local) endOfHour 2026-10-24 18:00:00 <- correct endOfDay 2026-10-24 18:00:00 <- should be 2026-10-25 00:00:00 so the chart puts 00:00 at 18:00 yesterday and everything ends up 6 hours off. it looks like the chart always labels its right edge as 24:00, so the further you are from midnight the worse it gets. restarting PerfPowerServices (`sudo killall PerfPowerServices`) doesn't fix it, the new process sends the same values right away. macos 27.0.1 (26A434). this was fine on macos 26. looks like the same bug as https://developer.apple.com/forums/thread/852392
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
119
Activity
2d
Account pending
Hi everyone, I purchased an Apple Developer Program membership about three days ago. The payment has already been successfully charged to my bank account, but my account is still showing the status “Pending” with the message “Subscribe your membership.” I haven’t received any confirmation email or any request for additional information since completing the purchase. I’m curious if others have experienced a similar delay recently, and how long it took before your developer account was fully activated. Any insights or experiences would be greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance!
Replies
20
Boosts
7
Views
4.3k
Activity
2d
Blocked in Public Beta?
I am wondering. For several OS versions, I have been unable to sign in to the public beta. Has anyone else experienced this? I attempted to work with support, but it does not appear they understand what is going on, or... You see, when I have been evaluating Apple products and services (I had beta tested for so many releases), I was quite detailed in business concepts, ideas of the culture, and the impacts that the organization has and outcomes that may come from their culture. Well, I was not intending to actually send those because they were only for me and like a journal for me to reference aspects like emotions, psychosis -how different activities and experiences impacted different lenses (empathy), and some of the dynamic evaluated actions like a game of chess. Well, I accidentally sent them. I'm sure it terrified whoever read it. Apple has not been very honest with me; no emails were received outlining concerns about the content. However, my account has been unable to access Beta now for quite some time. I don't even remember when it stopped. I have tried to unenroll (but it won't allow me to), I have tried to reenroll, etc. I have cleared the cache, I have deleted profiles, and removed anything that could interfere, but it does not seem to want to connect. The only thing I can think of is that maybe there is a clash between a developer profile and a public beta profile? Perhaps I am somehow enrolled as a developer? I have not built out any apps or anything like that. Also, I have never made any money from my feedback. Though I should. I am very good at identifying operational gaps between end-user connectivity and actual usage. Organic growth is a good sign of a good quality product. Nonetheless, for the longest time, I did not have the money, nor really the professional need to pay for the developer program. I'm just curious if anyone else out there is encountering similar issues.
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
141
Activity
2d
Account
Hi Community! I'm having an issue with the enrolment process, which seems to be stuck "In review" for 3 weeks now. The current status: Your documentation is in review. We received your documents and are processing your enrollment.The timeline: Oct 12: Enrolment signed and received Oct 21: I received a request to send additional documents - which were sent on that exact day. Oct 30: I requested a status update - no reply since then (retried on Nov 9, Nov 10 and today). Is anyone else experiencing a similar situation? Wanted to make sure that my request didn't fall into the void :p Thanks!
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
169
Activity
2d
Apple Developer enrollment paid, but account now shows “Not Eligible”
Title: Apple Developer enrollment paid, but account now shows “Not Eligible” Hello, I recently enrolled in the Apple Developer Program using my Apple Account. I completed the enrollment process and paid the membership fee using Apple Pay. The payment was successfully charged, and during the enrollment process I was told that I would receive an email shortly regarding the enrollment. However, I never received that email. When I now log in to my Apple Developer account, it says that my account is not eligible for the Apple Developer Program. The membership fee has already been charged, so I would like to understand what happened to my enrollment and whether the payment can be associated with my application. Could someone please advise me on what I should do next or how I can have the enrollment and payment reviewed? Thank you.
Replies
10
Boosts
2
Views
1.2k
Activity
2d
Problems uploading screenshots for more than a day
Hello! I am preparing a couple of apps for approval, and suddenly can not upload screenshots to the app store. When I drag and drop into the interface, it accepts them, shows that they are being processed, and after a minute or so, says that there is a problem, and to try again later. It's been doing this for more than a day. Has anyone else seen this? Dave
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
239
Activity
4d
Individual enrollment – wrong address is locked on my pending enrollment, can't edit it
Hi, I'm enrolling in the Apple Developer Program as an individual. I made a mistake in my address during enrollment. I tried to start the enrollment again with the same Apple Account, but it brings back the same wrong address and I can't edit it. The Membership details section doesn't appear in my account because the enrollment is still pending. Type: Individual Payment: paid on November 8th 2026 ID verification: not uploaded yet Could someone from Apple please: Correct the address on my enrollment, or reset it so I can enter the right address myself? Cancel any duplicate enrollment, so only one remains? I'm happy to provide proof of address. I haven't uploaded my ID or continued, because I don't want the wrong address verified. Thank you!
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
213
Activity
4d
What does this mean
I recently paid for my Apple developer on Apple approve it for few minutes later I get this message from Apple " We're having a problem with your payment. Order Number: D005486847 Ordered On November 13, 2026 To avoid a delay in receiving your order, contact us via the Developer page to change your payment information. You may contact your card provider to find more information. If after 7 days we're still unable to process your payment, your order will be canceled. If you have any questions, contact us at devpayment@apple.com. For your protection, do not submit credit card information via email or form. " I can help, but feel it will be all successful. what should i do?
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
71
Activity
5d
Enrollment paid over 48 hours ago — membership still inactive
Hello Apple Developer Support, I purchased the Apple Developer Program membership two days ago, and my order is confirmed in the Apple Store - Order Number W1814011542 | Ordered on November 07, 2026. However, my Apple Developer account still prompts me to purchase the membership and says to allow 48 hours for processing. More than 48 hours have now passed, and my membership remains inactive. I have also submitted a support request, but the issue is still unresolved. Could you please check my payment and enrollment status, confirm whether any further action is required from me, and let me know when my membership will be activated? Is it normal for activation to take longer than 48 hours? My previous support case ID is 30000009068984. Thank you for your assistance.
Replies
6
Boosts
1
Views
238
Activity
5d
macOS 27 – Minimized windows at the bottom of the screen missing when showing application windows
Right/Control-clicking an app in the Dock and doing ”Show All Windows” used to show any minimized windows for that app at the bottom of the screen. Since macOS 27 they don't show up there anymore. In macOS 26 they do. Why was this feature removed? I hope it wasn't intentional as it is quite handy to see the minimized windows there and being able to navigate to them from the keyboard (arrows). Which takes me to the the Mission Control feature that is showing all app windows – why won't pressing tab in that view do anything? I think a tab press should move focus to the frontmost window in the next app in this view. Also, maybe it would be good to as an option show the app icon of the app one is switching to when pressing tab after Mission Control for the current app windows are in view. Now it switches to the next app's windows, but it can take some time to get to terms with which app's windows I'm actually looking at. I think showing the app icon quicky (or persinstantly somewhere) would help the user understanding what app's windows are being looked at more quickly. Some more love for Mission Control, please! :)
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
66
Activity
5d
Home content caching with an intermittently available MacBook — options for an older Mac mini or another device?
Hello everyone, I am looking for technical guidance on maintaining a content cache for private use on my home network. I currently use my MacBook to handle the registration of a cache running on a Linux/Docker server. The MacBook is a regularly used laptop, so it is not always awake or connected to my home network. I would like to understand whether an older Mac mini or another device could take over this role reliably. For cost reasons, I would prefer not to purchase a Mac mini M1 or newer solely for this purpose. The implementation I am experimenting with is Maurice’s Open Apple Cache project. It handles the actual caching on Linux and uses a small macOS helper to register the cache with Apple. I understand that this is an experimental third-party project using private macOS interfaces, rather than an Apple-supported implementation. To clarify, I understand that the Docker-based setup is not Apple’s preferred or officially supported approach. My preferred solution would actually be to use an older Mac as a dedicated, always-on content cache, ideally running Apple’s built-in Content Caching service. The Linux/Docker setup is an experiment rather than a requirement. I would therefore particularly welcome guidance on whether an older Intel Mac could still provide a reliable solution for a household with current Apple devices, and which hardware and macOS requirements I should consider. The recurring problem is that the cache becomes undiscoverable while the MacBook is asleep or unavailable. The Linux service continues running, its health checks remain successful, and a direct download test still produces a cache HIT. However, Apple devices no longer discover it automatically. For example, AssetCacheLocatorUtil returned the following on the MacBook after the problem occurred: --- Information for system services: Checking whether there might be content caches available... There might be content caches available. Finding refreshed content caches supporting shared caching... Found 0 content caches --- Information for user 502 (results for other users may be different): Finding refreshed content caches supporting shared caching... Found 0 content caches Testing all found content caches for reachability... No content caches to test.The helper’s status file still showed "state": "registered", but its last successful registration was approximately 13 hours old. After I manually ran the registration helper again, the cache became discoverable and was reported as healthy. No changes to the Docker service were necessary. The helper currently runs as a LaunchAgent and attempts registration every 3,000 seconds. Its registration response reports a heartbeat interval of 3,300 seconds. I do not know whether that interval corresponds to the actual registration lifetime, so I would appreciate clarification rather than assuming a specific expiry time. My questions are: What is Apple’s recommended approach for home content caching when no Mac is continuously available? Could an older Intel Mac mini reliably perform the registration and renewal role, even if the actual cache remains on another server? Is registration from a system LaunchDaemon, without an interactive user login, technically possible? Are there relevant restrictions involving AuthKit or the execution context? Are there public APIs, documentation, or Apple open-source components that could help implement this functionality on older hardware or another platform? Is there a supported way to maintain discovery during longer periods when the registering Mac is asleep or offline? I would also appreciate Apple’s perspective on whether a project such as Open Apple Cache is a reasonable alternative for private households without an always-on Mac, or whether a different architecture would be preferable. This is solely for sharing Apple software updates and App Store downloads among devices within my household. Thank you for any technical guidance or pointers to relevant documentation. Kind regards, Philipp
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
48
Activity
5d
Individual enrollment stuck for 9 days after ID verification – app says I can't continue, website asks me to pay again
Hi everyone, I enrolled in the Apple Developer Program as an individual (Argentina) on November 2 and paid the US$99 fee. The payment is confirmed. On November 3–4 I uploaded my national ID (DNI) as requested, and Apple confirmed receipt. Since then, nothing has changed: the account still isn't active and I haven't received any further emails. Right now I'm getting two contradictory messages: In the Apple Developer app, it says enrollment can't be completed from the app. On the website (https://www.google.com/url?q=http://developer.apple.com/account&source=gmail&ust=1794536143988000&sa=E), it shows "Purchase your membership", as if I hadn't paid. But the charge already went through and I have the order confirmation. I don't want to pay twice, so I haven't touched that button. What I've tried: Opened a support case (Case ID 30000004906936) and followed up by email from the case page. No reply so far. Tried to request a phone call, but it shows as unavailable due to high volume. My app is ready to submit (it's already in closed testing on Google Play), and everything on the iOS side is blocked until the membership is activated. Is this normal while the ID is under review? Is there anything else I can do, or could someone from Apple take a look at the case? Thanks!
Replies
3
Boosts
1
Views
144
Activity
5d
Digital Services Act verification delays and lack of support communication
I’m posting because several developers have reported lengthy delays with Digital Services Act trader verification, with little visibility into what is happening or when they can expect a decision. Some developers report waiting more than four weeks, others two weeks. My own verification has been pending for 10 days. Contacting support does not always help: developers describe receiving no response, or waiting another two weeks for a reply. We understand that verification takes time and that some cases require additional checks. What is frustrating is the uncertainty: no meaningful status updates, no clear indication of whether anything is missing, and no reliable timeframe. We pay an annual Apple Developer Program membership fee... that does not mean every request should receive immediate approval, but timely communication and respectful support are reasonable expectations especially when these processes affect our ability to distribute an app and plan a launch. What is the current expected timeframe for DSA trader verification...When should developers escalate a pending verification, and through which channel? How can we confirm whether our submission is complete or requires additional information? Can developers receive meaningful progress updates instead of remaining indefinitely in “Pending Review”? For developers who have recently completed this process, how long did it take, and was there a support channel that actually helped? The concern is not simply waiting. It is having no useful information or assistance while we wait.
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
63
Activity
5d