Create elegant and intuitive apps that integrate seamlessly with Apple platforms.

All subtopics
Posts under Design topic

Post

Replies

Boosts

Views

Activity

SwiftUI Architecture Guide
Application Types Applications are divided into Document-based and Library-based. A document-based application stores user data in individual, standalone files. Users manually name and organize those files in a local system or synced cloud storage such as iCloud. The software typically opens multiple windows for different projects. This framing is for standalone, complex files that need to be shared, exported, or handled independently. A library-based application manages data in one unified, central repository, locally or through remote cloud databases. Spotify, Netflix, and Notion are the examples shown. The file system is hidden; updates are saved automatically in real time; and a single window supports browsing, search, and access to the synchronized data collection from any device. Model Types Four model types: Data, Domain, Application, and Presentation. Apple Platforms In Apple MVC (AppKit / UIKit), the model branches to Data, Domain, and Presentation. In SwiftUI, Model branches to Data and Domain. Project Structure SwiftUI App Folders Swift Package Folders App Modularization Not every module in a large application needs to be extracted into a separate framework or Swift Package. Logical modularization can also be achieved through a well-organized folder structure within the main project. Introduce separate packages or frameworks only when there is a clear benefit, such as independent reuse, distribution, build isolation or ownership. Avoid unnecessary project and dependency management overhead. State Management & Data Flow Source of truth is “a key concept in SwiftUI”: a single place to store a piece of data, with everywhere else reading the same piece of data. Environment is SwiftUI’s native dependency-injection mechanism. It allows shared dependencies, domain models, and services to be injected at the appropriate view-hierarchy level and accessed where needed without explicit parameter passing or unnecessary coupling. It is described as a tool for managing dependencies and sharing state across the view hierarchy. Domain Model Ownership Domain Models should be owned by the highest relevant SwiftUI view in the hierarchy that defines their context and lifecycle. NavigationStack owns the Domain Models for its navigation context and makes them available to descendant views through @Environment. When a NavigationStack is embedded in a TabView or NavigationSplitView, ownership moves up to the TabView or NavigationSplitView so the models can be shared across tabs or split views. The stated result is clear ownership scope, sharing where needed, and isolation between independent navigation contexts. Previews & UI Testing Environment injection makes SwiftUI Previews and UI Tests easier to configure by allowing real Domain Models to be replaced with mock or dummy instances. Views can be tested independently with controlled data and predictable states, without requiring real services, network requests, or application setup. Domain and Data Model Examples For a library-based app with remote data. Additional Domain Model Examples E-commerce Catalog, ShoppingCart, OrderHistory, Wishlist Banking MyAccounts, MyCards, MyTransactions, MyInvestments Social Network Feed, Conversations, Notifications, Friends Healthcare MyAppointments, MedicalHistory, Prescriptions, MyHealth Education Courses, MyCourses, Assignments, MyGrades, LearningProgress Real Estate PropertyCatalog, MyProperties, Favorites, Appointments Hotel Booking Destinations, Search, MyBookings, TravelHistory Food Delivery RestaurantCatalog, ShoppingCart, MyOrders, DeliveryTracking Project Management Projects, MyTasks, TeamMembers, Notifications Insurance MyPolicies, MyClaims, Coverage, Documents Smart Home MyHomes, Devices, Automations, EnergyUsage Fitness MyPlans, MyProgress, MyGoals, WorkoutHistory Other Search, Dashboard, Favorites, Notifications, Settings, ActivityHistory, Recommendations, Subscription, DocumentLibrary ViewModel? - MVVM In SwiftUI, the View encapsulates the UI content (body), its state (properties), and its actions or tasks (functions). This is possible because SwiftUI is designed around a declarative, state-driven UI model. In Android and .NET platforms, a separate ViewModel is typically required to hold and manage the View's state. Projects that intoduce ViewModels in SwiftUI add unnecessary architectural complexity, boilerplate, and code duplication; synchronization issues; unclear state ownership; additional lifecycle management; more abstractions; harder debugging; and increased maintenance, without meaningful benefits over SwiftUI's native state management. In UIKit, introducing a separate ViewModel layer is often unnecessary, as UIViewController already serves as the presentation model, handling presentation logic and coordinating the view. Non-UI responsibilities can be delegated to dedicated ModelControllers or Managers, avoiding unnecessary layers and abstractions. Domain Models vs. ViewModels Domain Models are view-independent, while ViewModels are view-dependent. A ViewModel is tightly coupled to the structure, state, and lifecycle of a specific View. Whenever the View code changes, its ViewModel often requires corresponding coding changes, and vice versa, creating additional maintenance and synchronization overhead. Domain Models, on the other hand, represent application context and business functionality independently of the UI. This separation preserves UI independence and allows the same Domain Models to be shared across different screens and platforms, such as iPhone, iPhone Duo, iPad, and macOS, without duplicating or adapting business logic for each View. This makes Domain Models a more scalable and maintainable approach for modern SwiftUI applications, particularly those targeting multiple screen sizes and platforms.
1
0
241
19h
New App Rejected Under Guideline 4.3(a) on Both iOS and tvOS — Seeking Clarification
Hi everyone, I’d like to share my experience with the first release of my app and ask for some guidance. Submission details App ID: 6829444660 Platforms: iOS and tvOS (Apple TV) Initially submitted: November 1, 2026, at 7:17 PM Rejection received: November 13, 2026, at 9:30 PM Rejection reason: Guideline 4.3(a) — Design — Spam Both the iOS and Apple TV submissions received the same rejection at the same time. How the app was built I personally developed the app using UIKit, with some parts built in SwiftUI. I also created the visual assets myself using Canva. AI was not involved in writing or designing the app; its involvement was limited to testing-related assistance. Having personally worked on the implementation and visual design, it was discouraging to see the app classified as spam. I believe there may be a misunderstanding about my submission, and I would appreciate an opportunity to clarify it. What I’m asking for Could an Apple representative help identify the specific elements or duplication concerns that led to this rejection? Clear, actionable feedback would help me understand: Which aspects of the app raised concerns under Guideline 4.3(a). What changes, if any, are needed to address those concerns. What supporting information I can provide to help clarify the situation. This project means a lot to me. I respect the review process and want to meet Apple’s requirements. I would sincerely appreciate a reconsideration of my submission and clear guidance on how to move forward. Has anyone experienced a simultaneous 4.3(a) rejection on iOS and tvOS and successfully resolved it? Thank you for taking the time to read this. Any guidance would mean a great deal to me.
1
0
135
1d
Request to remove horizontal blank space for keyboard extensions on iPhone Duo.
I have a custom iOS keyboard extension app. On iPhone Duo, the system forces keyboard extensions inside a container that is narrower than the phone's screen, specifically by adding extra 7 points on the leading and trailing edge in portrait. This creates both a visual and functional blank space on both sides of the keyboard. My keyboard relies on side swipes, which are much more annoying to perform when the keyboard does not occupy full width of the screen. All other devices iPhones before the Duo propely stretch the keyboard to full width, so this is a new issue. Please, reconsider this decision. I believe a better way to handle this is by setting the safe area layout, instead of limiting the container's width itself. I don't see any benefit to protecting these 7 points on each side. Keyboards that don't care will still stay within the limit by respecting the horizontal safe area, while others would get the benefit of better customization.
0
0
102
1w
iPadOS 27.2 — Software keyboard fails to appear in Swift Playgrounds apps (regression compared with iPadOS 26.2)
The on-screen software keyboard does not appear when editing SwiftUI TextField controls in applications created and executed using Swift Playgrounds on iPadOS 27.2. The issue is reproducible in a completely new, minimal Swift Playgrounds application, independently of any existing application code. Steps to reproduce 1. Open Swift Playgrounds on an iPad running iPadOS 27.2. 2. Create a new blank SwiftUI application. 3. Add a standard TextField bound to a @State String. 4. Run the application using Play. 5. Tap the TextField with a finger. Actual result The TextField displays the insertion cursor and responds to touch interactions, but the software keyboard never appears. Long-pressing the TextField displays the Paste / AutoFill context menu. Handwriting input using Apple Pencil Pro works, but the software keyboard remains unavailable. Disabling Scribble in iPadOS settings does not resolve the problem. The software keyboard works normally in Apple Notes on the same iPad. This issue prevents normal text entry and testing in an actively developed payroll management application built entirely with Swift Playgrounds. The problem also occurs in a completely new sample application, indicating that it is not specific to the payroll application’s code. Request Please investigate this apparent regression affecting software keyboard presentation in Swift Playgrounds on iPadOS 27.2. A fix or an official workaround would be greatly appreciated.
0
1
153
1w
“How can I update an existing Apple Arcade game submission?”
Hello, I’m an independent developer and have already submitted my game, Siege Chess, for Apple Arcade consideration through the submission form. Since submitting, I’ve continued development and testing. The new version now works on Mac, iPhone, iPad and Apple TV. My original submission included a link to my website, which contains gameplay videos and details of the game. Is there an official way to update an existing submission with additional platform support and current development information? I’d like to keep the Arcade team informed without creating a duplicate submission. I’d also appreciate clarification on whether developers receive an acknowledgement or reference number after submitting, as I haven’t received one. Thank you for any guidance. Jeremy Griffin
0
0
75
3w
Design-Copycats Rejection
Hi, since last month, I’ve been trying to publish my new game "Fractured Lands: Adventure RPG". Me and the marketing team with which I work believe that this game is unique and has strong potential. But unfortunately, the game is not being accepted on the App Store due to a Design - Copycats issue related to guideline 4.1, and now the verification times are taking more than a week. I’ve tried everything to resolve the problem by changing the screenshots, description, keywords, game name, icons, and even all metadata that could cause issues in the build like the trees/rocks models and all textures. But nothing seems to work. I keep receiving the same rejection after several days of waiting. Here is the full message: Guideline 4.1(a) - Design - Copycats Issue Description The app still contains third-party content similar to a popular app or game already available on the App Store, from a developer's website or distribution source, or from a third-party platform. This creates a misleading association with another developer's app or intellectual property. Specifically, the app includes references to Minecraft. Also I've already tried contacting the Apple Review Team with no responses yet since 30 September. I don't know what to do and I would need help. Thank you
2
0
219
3w
Swipe to go back still broken with Zoom navigation transition.
When you use .navigationTransition(.zoom(sourceID: "placeholder", in: placehoder)) for navigation animation, going back using the swipe gesture is still very buggy on IOS26. I know it has been mentioned in other places like here: https://developer.apple.com/forums/thread/796805?answerId=856846022#856846022 but nothing seems to have been done to fix this issue. Here is a video showing the bug comparing when the back button is used vs swipe to go back: https://imgur.com/a/JgEusRH I wish there was a way to at least disable the swipe back gesture until this bug is fixed.
12
4
3.6k
Oct ’26
Time-Sensitive: iPhone Duo Launch — Design Guidance for App Store Featuring Assets and Multitasking Presentation
Hello Apple Design Team, I’m an independent AI engineer with a strong background in product design, preparing to bring a new AI-powered application to market alongside a major iOS update featuring native support for iPhone Duo. With launch approaching, I’m looking for guidance on how developers should visually communicate Duo-specific experiences, particularly when preparing App Store screenshots, promotional assets, and featuring nominations. Specifically, are there examples, templates, or recommended approaches for presenting: Multitasking: Two* applications working side by side. Paired apps: Demonstrating workflows between complementary applications. Folded states: Communicating how an application adapts to different device configurations. Screenshot composition: Are larger developers using headlines, explanatory text, and custom layouts within their Duo screenshots, or are they primarily submitting unmodified simulator captures and device renders? App Store featuring: What types of visual assets best communicate Duo-specific functionality in featuring nominations? As an independent developer, I have very few public references for how larger development teams are preparing their launch materials. I’m particularly interested in understanding what Apple Design considers a strong visual demonstration of Duo integration, beyond simply showing an application running on the device. For example, should screenshots emphasize the actual interface and system multitasking experience, or is it appropriate to incorporate marketing headlines and supporting visual elements to explain the workflow? Are there recommended assets, design guidelines, templates, or examples that independent developers can reference before submitting their updates and featuring nominations? This is time-sensitive given the upcoming launch and associated submission deadlines. Any guidance would be greatly appreciated. Thank you for supporting the independent developer community.
Topic: Design SubTopic: General Tags:
3
0
2.9k
Oct ’26
Apple HomeView
With Apple HomeView announced today, is there any developer guidance on designing and optimizing existing iOS applications for the new platform? Very cool product!
Topic: Design SubTopic: General Tags:
2
2
2.2k
Oct ’26
SwiftUI design options needed
OK, I'm going to try SwiftUI one more time. Every other time I've tried it I've run into major blockages that prevented it from being usable. So far I've code up this basic design (see screenshot at end). It's a common thing: Filters in the left sidebar, filtered assets in the center list (ignore the temp IDs for debugging purposes), and a detail view of the selected asset on the right. I have no part of the filters figured out yet, so I wouldn't mind getting advice of how to use that to filter the SwiftData. It's currently just using the common @Query to get all the items into a var of the main ContentView. As for the asset list and detail view, my current layout works, but the detail only shows for the first item clicked. Rather than show my SwiftUI code, it might be best to just ask for expert opinions about what is the right way to achieve this design. I want it to run on macOS and iOS. The details field all need to be editable. I'm currently doing this by declaring a struct as such: struct TitledField:View { let title:String; @Binding var value:String; var body:some View { LabeledContent("\(self.title):") { TextField(self.title, text:$value) .labelsHidden(); } } }
2
0
435
Oct ’26
Spam Rejection Flutter VPN App
Hi! I’ve just received my seventh rejection for the exact same reason — Guideline 4.3(a) (Spam) — with no real hope of moving forward. I have been developing a free cross-platform VPN app using Flutter since May 12, 2026, continuously adding new features and refining the codebase. Although the iOS version currently boasts the most extensive functionality, it is still insufficient to successfully pass the review process. Before the last submission, I had a review call with an Apple representative who told me the key issue was "code similarity". I spent time improving the Xray VPN core and optimizing traffic routing. Then, after making minor UI tweaks and leaving the description virtually unchanged, I submitted a new version — only to be rejected again. Honestly, I’m at a loss as to what the problem could be. The app features a well-crafted, proprietary codebase and unique functionality that I haven't seen anywhere else, despite extensive research. Recent iterations have added: A modular configuration builder for VLESS/VMess/Trojan/Shadowsocks protocols that flags user errors during key creation, suggests options, and pings the specified address; VPN usage statistics — broken down by hour, data saved, and frequently visited resources (data is collected only with user consent and deleted upon request); Data usage display aligned with the imported subscription. Could the issue stem from the nature of a cross-platform Flutter app built for iOS? Is it possible that the default codebase simply cannot achieve the level of uniqueness Apple demands? I’m starting to lose hope that publishing a Flutter VPN app is even possible. It feels like the App Store simply doesn't approve apps of this type anymore, regardless of their functionality. Please share your experience in resolving issues like this — specifically, how you managed to pass the review after a "Spam 4.3(a)" rejection? Perhaps someone has also submitted a Flutter VPN app based on Xray Core for review? External TestFlight link from the 6th submission: https://testflight.apple.com/join/cp7a1yMC. To have full access to app, paste key on the initial screen: https://kuzya.fit/sub/oyFnd_p3C0q4u0w4
1
0
273
Oct ’26
How can I start developing my first game with Xcode and Reality Composer Pro on my own? 🎛️
Hello everyone!! 😊🤗 I'm starting to learn development for Apple platforms and I'd like to ask for some guidance on how to get started. My goal is to gradually develop my own video game using Xcode and Reality Composer Pro. The idea is to create an educational game with 3D environments and elements, so I also want to learn programming, experience design, and 3D content creation as I progress ⭐️ At the moment, I don't have much money to afford to hire developers to mentor me or take expensive courses 😔( My mother is sick and all our resources and budget are focused on her and her treatment. ) but I do have something I think is very important: a strong desire to learn, time, and the willingness to study and practice. I don't expect someone else to do the project for me; I want to learn how to build it myself. My main question is: where should I begin? I already have experience playing Swift Playgrounds, and I find it fascinating 🤩 but I'm looking for the next step: I'd like to know what Apple concepts, courses, documentation, or resources you would recommend I study first to learn how to use Xcode and Reality Composer Pro correctly, especially with the Apple Developer tutorials. Which videos specifically do you recommend I study? If anyone started in a similar way or has experience developing apps or games with these tools, I would greatly appreciate any advice on a learning path. Thank you so much for taking the time to read this and for any guidance you can give me! You truly don't know what this means to me. Thank you so much. 🙏🚀
2
0
1.1k
Oct ’26
I need a iOS dev team for
A Apple Music application model that I submitted for this project account, was accepted, but I’m not a developer or designer. I am a musician/ producer. This will be an exclusive Apple ONLY app. due to the actual features. IOS, MacOS drivers, DAW, wallet, graphics, NFT’s. designer developers, if you love building master code LETS GO….
1
0
235
Oct ’26
iPhone Duo - globe button appeared in RC 1 - intended change or bug?
In Xcode 27.1 RC 1 the native keyboard layout has been changed and now it shows the globe button. It looks like a bug but I'm not sure. Is the keyboard going to display the globe button in the final release? On top of that, the keyboard extension tells not to show its own globe button, so it's another point confirming that this is RC 1 regression bug. Xcode 27.1 Beta 1: Xcode 27.1 RC 1:
3
0
1.1k
Oct ’26
Dismiss/Close button - leading or trailing edge?
What is the recommended position of the "X" button dismissing a modal sheet on iOS? When we have "X" and "✓" the case is easy, but what if we just have "X" button? For example, on a "What's New" screen. I found guidelines here: https://developer.apple.com/design/human-interface-guidelines/sheets Based on resizable sheets presented there, the "X" button should be on leading edge. However, iOS is inconsistent and sometimes it presents the button on the leading edge and sometimes on the trailing edge. How do you approach it? Do you prefer having it on the leading or trailing edge? SwiftUI provides ToolbarItem(placement: .cancellationAction) , but it doesn't feel like the right placement. cancellationAction sounds like something for actionable sheets when we have something to be cancelled. I'm missing placement: .dismiss :).
1
0
1.5k
Oct ’26
Screen Layout and Camera Rotation Behavior on iPhone Duo - Does Build Environment Matter?
I'm developing with the following setup: Xcode 26.2 Minimum Deployment Target: iOS 15.0 Currently using AppDelegate only I have three questions: Screen Display on iPhone Duo From what I understand, when an app built with this configuration runs on iPhone Duo, the content appears in the center area while both sides show vertical empty bars. Does this layout stay the same when the device is rotated? Camera Rotation Behavior When I open the camera and rotate the device, does the camera view automatically rotate to match the device's rotation direction? UI Rendering Differences Between Xcode Versions If I build the same app with Xcode 27 and Xcode 26, and then install both versions on the same devices (regular iPhone and iPhone Duo), are there any differences in how the UI is drawn? If there are differences, does this mean the UI rendering follows the build environment (Xcode version) rather than the runtime environment?
0
0
224
Oct ’26
FALSE SPAM CLAIM: Spam Flag After Apple Confirmed Our App Was NOT Spam
We need Apple to urgently remove the spam flag on our app. This is not a request for another generic explanation of the rejection. We previously had a Webex meeting with Ewelina from Apple, during which we explained the app, its purpose, and the changes made in response to the prior rejection. We were explicitly told that our app is not spam, (and was never a spam) that the issue would be addressed, and that we could confidently resubmit the app. We relied on that assurance and resubmitted. Yet we received the same spam rejection again. This is causing immediate and substantial financial harm. We are already paying commitments to Plaid and Checkbook, fees to other providers, and salaries to employees who cannot perform the work they were hired to do while our app remains blocked. These costs continue every day without a launch, and our company is facing significant financial distress. We have had to cancel our launch event three times. The third cancellation followed this latest rejection, after Apple told us we could confidently resubmit. We made financial and operational decisions based on that guidance. Please urgently escalate this to someone who can review the Webex meeting with Ewelina, remove the spam designation, and ensure our app is not rejected again on the same basis Apple already told us did not apply. We need a concrete resolution now. We cannot keep paying providers and employees, cancelling launch plans, and absorbing losses because the same flag continues to be applied. If anyone here has experienced the same situation or knows how to get this escalated to someone who can resolve it, we would be extremely grateful for your help.
0
0
329
Sep ’26
My App is in review for too long and I need to publish it before the second week of October. Any help?
I submitted an app and it got rejected under guidelines 4. I then submitted a revised build for it and it's still waiting in review after 48+ hours. I had already applied to the expedited queue since it's a seasonal app meant for the month of October. Is there any way I can get my app reviews done faster?
1
0
238
Sep ’26
SwiftUI Architecture Guide
Application Types Applications are divided into Document-based and Library-based. A document-based application stores user data in individual, standalone files. Users manually name and organize those files in a local system or synced cloud storage such as iCloud. The software typically opens multiple windows for different projects. This framing is for standalone, complex files that need to be shared, exported, or handled independently. A library-based application manages data in one unified, central repository, locally or through remote cloud databases. Spotify, Netflix, and Notion are the examples shown. The file system is hidden; updates are saved automatically in real time; and a single window supports browsing, search, and access to the synchronized data collection from any device. Model Types Four model types: Data, Domain, Application, and Presentation. Apple Platforms In Apple MVC (AppKit / UIKit), the model branches to Data, Domain, and Presentation. In SwiftUI, Model branches to Data and Domain. Project Structure SwiftUI App Folders Swift Package Folders App Modularization Not every module in a large application needs to be extracted into a separate framework or Swift Package. Logical modularization can also be achieved through a well-organized folder structure within the main project. Introduce separate packages or frameworks only when there is a clear benefit, such as independent reuse, distribution, build isolation or ownership. Avoid unnecessary project and dependency management overhead. State Management & Data Flow Source of truth is “a key concept in SwiftUI”: a single place to store a piece of data, with everywhere else reading the same piece of data. Environment is SwiftUI’s native dependency-injection mechanism. It allows shared dependencies, domain models, and services to be injected at the appropriate view-hierarchy level and accessed where needed without explicit parameter passing or unnecessary coupling. It is described as a tool for managing dependencies and sharing state across the view hierarchy. Domain Model Ownership Domain Models should be owned by the highest relevant SwiftUI view in the hierarchy that defines their context and lifecycle. NavigationStack owns the Domain Models for its navigation context and makes them available to descendant views through @Environment. When a NavigationStack is embedded in a TabView or NavigationSplitView, ownership moves up to the TabView or NavigationSplitView so the models can be shared across tabs or split views. The stated result is clear ownership scope, sharing where needed, and isolation between independent navigation contexts. Previews & UI Testing Environment injection makes SwiftUI Previews and UI Tests easier to configure by allowing real Domain Models to be replaced with mock or dummy instances. Views can be tested independently with controlled data and predictable states, without requiring real services, network requests, or application setup. Domain and Data Model Examples For a library-based app with remote data. Additional Domain Model Examples E-commerce Catalog, ShoppingCart, OrderHistory, Wishlist Banking MyAccounts, MyCards, MyTransactions, MyInvestments Social Network Feed, Conversations, Notifications, Friends Healthcare MyAppointments, MedicalHistory, Prescriptions, MyHealth Education Courses, MyCourses, Assignments, MyGrades, LearningProgress Real Estate PropertyCatalog, MyProperties, Favorites, Appointments Hotel Booking Destinations, Search, MyBookings, TravelHistory Food Delivery RestaurantCatalog, ShoppingCart, MyOrders, DeliveryTracking Project Management Projects, MyTasks, TeamMembers, Notifications Insurance MyPolicies, MyClaims, Coverage, Documents Smart Home MyHomes, Devices, Automations, EnergyUsage Fitness MyPlans, MyProgress, MyGoals, WorkoutHistory Other Search, Dashboard, Favorites, Notifications, Settings, ActivityHistory, Recommendations, Subscription, DocumentLibrary ViewModel? - MVVM In SwiftUI, the View encapsulates the UI content (body), its state (properties), and its actions or tasks (functions). This is possible because SwiftUI is designed around a declarative, state-driven UI model. In Android and .NET platforms, a separate ViewModel is typically required to hold and manage the View's state. Projects that intoduce ViewModels in SwiftUI add unnecessary architectural complexity, boilerplate, and code duplication; synchronization issues; unclear state ownership; additional lifecycle management; more abstractions; harder debugging; and increased maintenance, without meaningful benefits over SwiftUI's native state management. In UIKit, introducing a separate ViewModel layer is often unnecessary, as UIViewController already serves as the presentation model, handling presentation logic and coordinating the view. Non-UI responsibilities can be delegated to dedicated ModelControllers or Managers, avoiding unnecessary layers and abstractions. Domain Models vs. ViewModels Domain Models are view-independent, while ViewModels are view-dependent. A ViewModel is tightly coupled to the structure, state, and lifecycle of a specific View. Whenever the View code changes, its ViewModel often requires corresponding coding changes, and vice versa, creating additional maintenance and synchronization overhead. Domain Models, on the other hand, represent application context and business functionality independently of the UI. This separation preserves UI independence and allows the same Domain Models to be shared across different screens and platforms, such as iPhone, iPhone Duo, iPad, and macOS, without duplicating or adapting business logic for each View. This makes Domain Models a more scalable and maintainable approach for modern SwiftUI applications, particularly those targeting multiple screen sizes and platforms.
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
241
Activity
19h
New App Rejected Under Guideline 4.3(a) on Both iOS and tvOS — Seeking Clarification
Hi everyone, I’d like to share my experience with the first release of my app and ask for some guidance. Submission details App ID: 6829444660 Platforms: iOS and tvOS (Apple TV) Initially submitted: November 1, 2026, at 7:17 PM Rejection received: November 13, 2026, at 9:30 PM Rejection reason: Guideline 4.3(a) — Design — Spam Both the iOS and Apple TV submissions received the same rejection at the same time. How the app was built I personally developed the app using UIKit, with some parts built in SwiftUI. I also created the visual assets myself using Canva. AI was not involved in writing or designing the app; its involvement was limited to testing-related assistance. Having personally worked on the implementation and visual design, it was discouraging to see the app classified as spam. I believe there may be a misunderstanding about my submission, and I would appreciate an opportunity to clarify it. What I’m asking for Could an Apple representative help identify the specific elements or duplication concerns that led to this rejection? Clear, actionable feedback would help me understand: Which aspects of the app raised concerns under Guideline 4.3(a). What changes, if any, are needed to address those concerns. What supporting information I can provide to help clarify the situation. This project means a lot to me. I respect the review process and want to meet Apple’s requirements. I would sincerely appreciate a reconsideration of my submission and clear guidance on how to move forward. Has anyone experienced a simultaneous 4.3(a) rejection on iOS and tvOS and successfully resolved it? Thank you for taking the time to read this. Any guidance would mean a great deal to me.
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
135
Activity
1d
Request to remove horizontal blank space for keyboard extensions on iPhone Duo.
I have a custom iOS keyboard extension app. On iPhone Duo, the system forces keyboard extensions inside a container that is narrower than the phone's screen, specifically by adding extra 7 points on the leading and trailing edge in portrait. This creates both a visual and functional blank space on both sides of the keyboard. My keyboard relies on side swipes, which are much more annoying to perform when the keyboard does not occupy full width of the screen. All other devices iPhones before the Duo propely stretch the keyboard to full width, so this is a new issue. Please, reconsider this decision. I believe a better way to handle this is by setting the safe area layout, instead of limiting the container's width itself. I don't see any benefit to protecting these 7 points on each side. Keyboards that don't care will still stay within the limit by respecting the horizontal safe area, while others would get the benefit of better customization.
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
102
Activity
1w
iPadOS 27.2 — Software keyboard fails to appear in Swift Playgrounds apps (regression compared with iPadOS 26.2)
The on-screen software keyboard does not appear when editing SwiftUI TextField controls in applications created and executed using Swift Playgrounds on iPadOS 27.2. The issue is reproducible in a completely new, minimal Swift Playgrounds application, independently of any existing application code. Steps to reproduce 1. Open Swift Playgrounds on an iPad running iPadOS 27.2. 2. Create a new blank SwiftUI application. 3. Add a standard TextField bound to a @State String. 4. Run the application using Play. 5. Tap the TextField with a finger. Actual result The TextField displays the insertion cursor and responds to touch interactions, but the software keyboard never appears. Long-pressing the TextField displays the Paste / AutoFill context menu. Handwriting input using Apple Pencil Pro works, but the software keyboard remains unavailable. Disabling Scribble in iPadOS settings does not resolve the problem. The software keyboard works normally in Apple Notes on the same iPad. This issue prevents normal text entry and testing in an actively developed payroll management application built entirely with Swift Playgrounds. The problem also occurs in a completely new sample application, indicating that it is not specific to the payroll application’s code. Request Please investigate this apparent regression affecting software keyboard presentation in Swift Playgrounds on iPadOS 27.2. A fix or an official workaround would be greatly appreciated.
Replies
0
Boosts
1
Views
153
Activity
1w
“How can I update an existing Apple Arcade game submission?”
Hello, I’m an independent developer and have already submitted my game, Siege Chess, for Apple Arcade consideration through the submission form. Since submitting, I’ve continued development and testing. The new version now works on Mac, iPhone, iPad and Apple TV. My original submission included a link to my website, which contains gameplay videos and details of the game. Is there an official way to update an existing submission with additional platform support and current development information? I’d like to keep the Arcade team informed without creating a duplicate submission. I’d also appreciate clarification on whether developers receive an acknowledgement or reference number after submitting, as I haven’t received one. Thank you for any guidance. Jeremy Griffin
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
75
Activity
3w
Design-Copycats Rejection
Hi, since last month, I’ve been trying to publish my new game "Fractured Lands: Adventure RPG". Me and the marketing team with which I work believe that this game is unique and has strong potential. But unfortunately, the game is not being accepted on the App Store due to a Design - Copycats issue related to guideline 4.1, and now the verification times are taking more than a week. I’ve tried everything to resolve the problem by changing the screenshots, description, keywords, game name, icons, and even all metadata that could cause issues in the build like the trees/rocks models and all textures. But nothing seems to work. I keep receiving the same rejection after several days of waiting. Here is the full message: Guideline 4.1(a) - Design - Copycats Issue Description The app still contains third-party content similar to a popular app or game already available on the App Store, from a developer's website or distribution source, or from a third-party platform. This creates a misleading association with another developer's app or intellectual property. Specifically, the app includes references to Minecraft. Also I've already tried contacting the Apple Review Team with no responses yet since 30 September. I don't know what to do and I would need help. Thank you
Replies
2
Boosts
0
Views
219
Activity
3w
Swipe to go back still broken with Zoom navigation transition.
When you use .navigationTransition(.zoom(sourceID: "placeholder", in: placehoder)) for navigation animation, going back using the swipe gesture is still very buggy on IOS26. I know it has been mentioned in other places like here: https://developer.apple.com/forums/thread/796805?answerId=856846022#856846022 but nothing seems to have been done to fix this issue. Here is a video showing the bug comparing when the back button is used vs swipe to go back: https://imgur.com/a/JgEusRH I wish there was a way to at least disable the swipe back gesture until this bug is fixed.
Replies
12
Boosts
4
Views
3.6k
Activity
Oct ’26
Time-Sensitive: iPhone Duo Launch — Design Guidance for App Store Featuring Assets and Multitasking Presentation
Hello Apple Design Team, I’m an independent AI engineer with a strong background in product design, preparing to bring a new AI-powered application to market alongside a major iOS update featuring native support for iPhone Duo. With launch approaching, I’m looking for guidance on how developers should visually communicate Duo-specific experiences, particularly when preparing App Store screenshots, promotional assets, and featuring nominations. Specifically, are there examples, templates, or recommended approaches for presenting: Multitasking: Two* applications working side by side. Paired apps: Demonstrating workflows between complementary applications. Folded states: Communicating how an application adapts to different device configurations. Screenshot composition: Are larger developers using headlines, explanatory text, and custom layouts within their Duo screenshots, or are they primarily submitting unmodified simulator captures and device renders? App Store featuring: What types of visual assets best communicate Duo-specific functionality in featuring nominations? As an independent developer, I have very few public references for how larger development teams are preparing their launch materials. I’m particularly interested in understanding what Apple Design considers a strong visual demonstration of Duo integration, beyond simply showing an application running on the device. For example, should screenshots emphasize the actual interface and system multitasking experience, or is it appropriate to incorporate marketing headlines and supporting visual elements to explain the workflow? Are there recommended assets, design guidelines, templates, or examples that independent developers can reference before submitting their updates and featuring nominations? This is time-sensitive given the upcoming launch and associated submission deadlines. Any guidance would be greatly appreciated. Thank you for supporting the independent developer community.
Topic: Design SubTopic: General Tags:
Replies
3
Boosts
0
Views
2.9k
Activity
Oct ’26
Apple HomeView
With Apple HomeView announced today, is there any developer guidance on designing and optimizing existing iOS applications for the new platform? Very cool product!
Topic: Design SubTopic: General Tags:
Replies
2
Boosts
2
Views
2.2k
Activity
Oct ’26
SwiftUI design options needed
OK, I'm going to try SwiftUI one more time. Every other time I've tried it I've run into major blockages that prevented it from being usable. So far I've code up this basic design (see screenshot at end). It's a common thing: Filters in the left sidebar, filtered assets in the center list (ignore the temp IDs for debugging purposes), and a detail view of the selected asset on the right. I have no part of the filters figured out yet, so I wouldn't mind getting advice of how to use that to filter the SwiftData. It's currently just using the common @Query to get all the items into a var of the main ContentView. As for the asset list and detail view, my current layout works, but the detail only shows for the first item clicked. Rather than show my SwiftUI code, it might be best to just ask for expert opinions about what is the right way to achieve this design. I want it to run on macOS and iOS. The details field all need to be editable. I'm currently doing this by declaring a struct as such: struct TitledField:View { let title:String; @Binding var value:String; var body:some View { LabeledContent("\(self.title):") { TextField(self.title, text:$value) .labelsHidden(); } } }
Replies
2
Boosts
0
Views
435
Activity
Oct ’26
Spam Rejection Flutter VPN App
Hi! I’ve just received my seventh rejection for the exact same reason — Guideline 4.3(a) (Spam) — with no real hope of moving forward. I have been developing a free cross-platform VPN app using Flutter since May 12, 2026, continuously adding new features and refining the codebase. Although the iOS version currently boasts the most extensive functionality, it is still insufficient to successfully pass the review process. Before the last submission, I had a review call with an Apple representative who told me the key issue was "code similarity". I spent time improving the Xray VPN core and optimizing traffic routing. Then, after making minor UI tweaks and leaving the description virtually unchanged, I submitted a new version — only to be rejected again. Honestly, I’m at a loss as to what the problem could be. The app features a well-crafted, proprietary codebase and unique functionality that I haven't seen anywhere else, despite extensive research. Recent iterations have added: A modular configuration builder for VLESS/VMess/Trojan/Shadowsocks protocols that flags user errors during key creation, suggests options, and pings the specified address; VPN usage statistics — broken down by hour, data saved, and frequently visited resources (data is collected only with user consent and deleted upon request); Data usage display aligned with the imported subscription. Could the issue stem from the nature of a cross-platform Flutter app built for iOS? Is it possible that the default codebase simply cannot achieve the level of uniqueness Apple demands? I’m starting to lose hope that publishing a Flutter VPN app is even possible. It feels like the App Store simply doesn't approve apps of this type anymore, regardless of their functionality. Please share your experience in resolving issues like this — specifically, how you managed to pass the review after a "Spam 4.3(a)" rejection? Perhaps someone has also submitted a Flutter VPN app based on Xray Core for review? External TestFlight link from the 6th submission: https://testflight.apple.com/join/cp7a1yMC. To have full access to app, paste key on the initial screen: https://kuzya.fit/sub/oyFnd_p3C0q4u0w4
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
273
Activity
Oct ’26
How can I start developing my first game with Xcode and Reality Composer Pro on my own? 🎛️
Hello everyone!! 😊🤗 I'm starting to learn development for Apple platforms and I'd like to ask for some guidance on how to get started. My goal is to gradually develop my own video game using Xcode and Reality Composer Pro. The idea is to create an educational game with 3D environments and elements, so I also want to learn programming, experience design, and 3D content creation as I progress ⭐️ At the moment, I don't have much money to afford to hire developers to mentor me or take expensive courses 😔( My mother is sick and all our resources and budget are focused on her and her treatment. ) but I do have something I think is very important: a strong desire to learn, time, and the willingness to study and practice. I don't expect someone else to do the project for me; I want to learn how to build it myself. My main question is: where should I begin? I already have experience playing Swift Playgrounds, and I find it fascinating 🤩 but I'm looking for the next step: I'd like to know what Apple concepts, courses, documentation, or resources you would recommend I study first to learn how to use Xcode and Reality Composer Pro correctly, especially with the Apple Developer tutorials. Which videos specifically do you recommend I study? If anyone started in a similar way or has experience developing apps or games with these tools, I would greatly appreciate any advice on a learning path. Thank you so much for taking the time to read this and for any guidance you can give me! You truly don't know what this means to me. Thank you so much. 🙏🚀
Replies
2
Boosts
0
Views
1.1k
Activity
Oct ’26
I need a iOS dev team for
A Apple Music application model that I submitted for this project account, was accepted, but I’m not a developer or designer. I am a musician/ producer. This will be an exclusive Apple ONLY app. due to the actual features. IOS, MacOS drivers, DAW, wallet, graphics, NFT’s. designer developers, if you love building master code LETS GO….
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
235
Activity
Oct ’26
iPhone Duo - globe button appeared in RC 1 - intended change or bug?
In Xcode 27.1 RC 1 the native keyboard layout has been changed and now it shows the globe button. It looks like a bug but I'm not sure. Is the keyboard going to display the globe button in the final release? On top of that, the keyboard extension tells not to show its own globe button, so it's another point confirming that this is RC 1 regression bug. Xcode 27.1 Beta 1: Xcode 27.1 RC 1:
Replies
3
Boosts
0
Views
1.1k
Activity
Oct ’26
Accent Color is broken in Xcode 27.1 RC 1
In Xcode 27.1 RC 1 there is a regression bug displaying incorrect accent color across the app. It worked correctly in Xcode 27.1 Beta 1. It affects borderPromintent top bar buttons and tab bars: https://x.com/kulik_wojciech/status/2107252543709692166?s=20 I already reported it as a bug: FB25074768
Replies
4
Boosts
0
Views
379
Activity
Oct ’26
Dismiss/Close button - leading or trailing edge?
What is the recommended position of the "X" button dismissing a modal sheet on iOS? When we have "X" and "✓" the case is easy, but what if we just have "X" button? For example, on a "What's New" screen. I found guidelines here: https://developer.apple.com/design/human-interface-guidelines/sheets Based on resizable sheets presented there, the "X" button should be on leading edge. However, iOS is inconsistent and sometimes it presents the button on the leading edge and sometimes on the trailing edge. How do you approach it? Do you prefer having it on the leading or trailing edge? SwiftUI provides ToolbarItem(placement: .cancellationAction) , but it doesn't feel like the right placement. cancellationAction sounds like something for actionable sheets when we have something to be cancelled. I'm missing placement: .dismiss :).
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
1.5k
Activity
Oct ’26
Screen Layout and Camera Rotation Behavior on iPhone Duo - Does Build Environment Matter?
I'm developing with the following setup: Xcode 26.2 Minimum Deployment Target: iOS 15.0 Currently using AppDelegate only I have three questions: Screen Display on iPhone Duo From what I understand, when an app built with this configuration runs on iPhone Duo, the content appears in the center area while both sides show vertical empty bars. Does this layout stay the same when the device is rotated? Camera Rotation Behavior When I open the camera and rotate the device, does the camera view automatically rotate to match the device's rotation direction? UI Rendering Differences Between Xcode Versions If I build the same app with Xcode 27 and Xcode 26, and then install both versions on the same devices (regular iPhone and iPhone Duo), are there any differences in how the UI is drawn? If there are differences, does this mean the UI rendering follows the build environment (Xcode version) rather than the runtime environment?
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
224
Activity
Oct ’26
FALSE SPAM CLAIM: Spam Flag After Apple Confirmed Our App Was NOT Spam
We need Apple to urgently remove the spam flag on our app. This is not a request for another generic explanation of the rejection. We previously had a Webex meeting with Ewelina from Apple, during which we explained the app, its purpose, and the changes made in response to the prior rejection. We were explicitly told that our app is not spam, (and was never a spam) that the issue would be addressed, and that we could confidently resubmit the app. We relied on that assurance and resubmitted. Yet we received the same spam rejection again. This is causing immediate and substantial financial harm. We are already paying commitments to Plaid and Checkbook, fees to other providers, and salaries to employees who cannot perform the work they were hired to do while our app remains blocked. These costs continue every day without a launch, and our company is facing significant financial distress. We have had to cancel our launch event three times. The third cancellation followed this latest rejection, after Apple told us we could confidently resubmit. We made financial and operational decisions based on that guidance. Please urgently escalate this to someone who can review the Webex meeting with Ewelina, remove the spam designation, and ensure our app is not rejected again on the same basis Apple already told us did not apply. We need a concrete resolution now. We cannot keep paying providers and employees, cancelling launch plans, and absorbing losses because the same flag continues to be applied. If anyone here has experienced the same situation or knows how to get this escalated to someone who can resolve it, we would be extremely grateful for your help.
Replies
0
Boosts
0
Views
329
Activity
Sep ’26
My App is in review for too long and I need to publish it before the second week of October. Any help?
I submitted an app and it got rejected under guidelines 4. I then submitted a revised build for it and it's still waiting in review after 48+ hours. I had already applied to the expedited queue since it's a seasonal app meant for the month of October. Is there any way I can get my app reviews done faster?
Replies
1
Boosts
0
Views
238
Activity
Sep ’26