Create elegant and intuitive apps that integrate seamlessly with Apple platforms.

All subtopics
Posts under Design topic

Post

Replies

Boosts

Views

Activity

Seeking Developer Insights Regarding 4.3(b) Review Response
We recently received feedback under Guideline 4.3(b) suggesting our app duplicates functionality found in other apps in this category. However, our app is fundamentally not a dating app. It is a conversation facilitator designed to foster meaningful connections for friendships, networking, and shared interests. While romantic connections may occur naturally, they are not the primary focus. Thus, we are seeking insights on this key question: How do developers effectively demonstrate feature differentiation to reviewers? We want to clearly show how our app’s functionality uniquely addresses user needs and provides value beyond existing solutions. Our Core Features: Our app introduces distinct features that differentiate it from traditional apps in this space: Paths: Psychology-based prompts embedded in chats encourage users to explore meaningful topics like values and aspirations. These prompts are dynamically triggered to keep conversations engaging and productive. Aura: A rewards system that incentivizes thoughtful, high-quality engagement by awarding points for meaningful conversations, which can unlock additional features. Spark Matches: Real-time, themed events pair users for structured, 15-minute conversations on topics like technology or travel. Curated prompts ensure the focus is on shared interests, not romance. Flame Matches: AI-personalized matches adapt to user conversations, connecting individuals based on compatibility. Chats begin anonymously, focusing on personalities rather than appearances, and are designed for platonic, professional, or friendship connections. Market Analysis: Our app addresses key gaps in the connection space: No apps embed conversation prompts directly into chats; nor do they trigger them regularly or dynamically, to foster deeper discussions over a sustained period. No apps have rewards systems designed to specifically incentivize meaningful engagement. No apps have matchmaking systems that adapt dynamically based on users’ past conversations. No apps support the combination of real-time, one-on-one themed conversations with curated prompts. Traction: As an incorporated business with over a year of experience, we have helped thousands of users build platonic, professional, and interest-based connections. For example, users in relationships join our events to find new friends, and professionals use Spark Matches to discuss shared interests like technology. Consistent feedback highlights our prompts and structured events as refreshing alternatives to superficial, appearance-driven platforms. Our rapidly growing user base has validated the demand for these features, and we would like to bring this experience natively to them via a mobile app on the App Store. Additional Context: While some basic chat functionality may overlap with existing platforms, our focus is on facilitating meaningful conversations and incentivizing a thoughtful conversation culture that represents a novel approach validated by user research and feedback. We welcome advice from developers who have successfully highlighted their app’s uniqueness when facing similar review challenges. Thank you in advance! :)
2
0
498
Jan ’25
A phone keyboard layout for easy typing!
Last November 13 I came up with a phone keyboard layout (strategy) that can make key size bigger hence less mistyping. The typical phone keyboard looks like this: My proposed keyboard looks like this: Essentially, it's a split keyboard with the left-hand part stacked above/below the right-hand part. Key size/width/height and the vertical distance between the left-hand part and right-hand part may be adjustable to suit different phone widths and user hand sizes. You guys can show the proposed keyboard's image on your phone and fit this keyboard to your phone width so you can actually simulate typing on it to see how it feels. On my phone, the letter keys in it are a little too big for my thumbs to reach the farthest keys, but as I said, key size should be adjustable to suit different phone widths and user hand sizes.
0
0
661
Oct ’24
Why is SwiftUI so broken and not improving layered UI functionality
Again and and again, I reach the point in a new application where I need to make structural changes in components and my data model, and the SwiftUI compiler fails to compile and just reports "I'm lost in the weeds", with no indication of what it was last working on, aside from a particular level in a multi-layered nested UI. This typically happens when a sub-views construction is not coded correctly because I changed that view and am looking for what broke, by just letting the compiler tell me what is not compatible. This is how refactoring has been done for ages and it's just amazingly frustrating that Apple engineers don't seem to understand nor care about this issue enough to fix it. Why does this problem persist through version after version of SwiftUI? Is no-one actually using it for anything?
1
0
90
Jul ’25
Your app included hard to read type or typography
I recently submitted a new app for review, but it has been rejected multiple times for vague reasons. The most recent rejection reason I received was unclear, leaving me unsure of what improvements are needed to get the app approved for the App Store. Does anyone have any advice on how to address this? Additionally, to Apple reviewers: Could you please provide more detailed feedback to help developers improve their apps? The repeated review process takes a significant amount of time, and guessing what needs to be fixed without clear guidance makes it even more challenging. ################################# The latest rejection reason I got is: Guideline 4.0 - Design We noticed an issue in your app that contributes to a lower-quality user experience than App Store users expect: Your app included hard to read type or typography. Since App Store users expect apps to be simple, refined, and easy to use, we want to call your attention to this design issue so you can make the appropriate changes. Next Steps Please revise your app to address all instances of the issue identified above.
Topic: Design SubTopic: General Tags:
1
0
455
Jan ’25
OCR does not work
Hi, I'm working with a very simple app that tries to read a coordinates card and past the data into diferent fields. The card's layout is COLUMNS from 1-10, ROWs from A-J and a two digit number for each cell. In my app, I have field for each of those cells (A1, A2...). I want that OCR to read that card and paste the info but I just cant. I have two problems. The camera won't close. It remains open until I press the button SAVE (this is not good because a user could take 3, 4, 5... pictures of the same card with, maybe, different results, and then? Which is the good one?). Then, after I press save, I can see the OCR kinda works ( the console prints all the date read) but the info is not pasted at all. Any idea? I know is hard to know what's wrong but I've tried chatgpt and all it does... just doesn't work This is the code from the scanview import SwiftUI import Vision import VisionKit struct ScanCardView: UIViewControllerRepresentable { @Binding var scannedCoordinates: [String: String] var useLettersForColumns: Bool var numberOfColumns: Int var numberOfRows: Int @Environment(.presentationMode) var presentationMode func makeUIViewController(context: Context) -> VNDocumentCameraViewController { let scannerVC = VNDocumentCameraViewController() scannerVC.delegate = context.coordinator return scannerVC } func updateUIViewController(_ uiViewController: VNDocumentCameraViewController, context: Context) {} func makeCoordinator() -> Coordinator { return Coordinator(self) } class Coordinator: NSObject, VNDocumentCameraViewControllerDelegate { let parent: ScanCardView init(_ parent: ScanCardView) { self.parent = parent } func documentCameraViewController(_ controller: VNDocumentCameraViewController, didFinishWith scan: VNDocumentCameraScan) { print("Escaneo completado, procesando imagen...") guard scan.pageCount > 0, let image = scan.imageOfPage(at: 0).cgImage else { print("No se pudo obtener la imagen del escaneo.") controller.dismiss(animated: true, completion: nil) return } recognizeText(from: image) DispatchQueue.main.async { print("Finalizando proceso OCR y cerrando la cámara.") controller.dismiss(animated: true, completion: nil) } } func documentCameraViewControllerDidCancel(_ controller: VNDocumentCameraViewController) { print("Escaneo cancelado por el usuario.") controller.dismiss(animated: true, completion: nil) } func documentCameraViewController(_ controller: VNDocumentCameraViewController, didFailWithError error: Error) { print("Error en el escaneo: \(error.localizedDescription)") controller.dismiss(animated: true, completion: nil) } private func recognizeText(from image: CGImage) { let request = VNRecognizeTextRequest { (request, error) in guard let observations = request.results as? [VNRecognizedTextObservation], error == nil else { print("Error en el reconocimiento de texto: \(String(describing: error?.localizedDescription))") DispatchQueue.main.async { self.parent.presentationMode.wrappedValue.dismiss() } return } let recognizedStrings = observations.compactMap { observation in observation.topCandidates(1).first?.string } print("Texto reconocido: \(recognizedStrings)") let filteredCoordinates = self.filterValidCoordinates(from: recognizedStrings) DispatchQueue.main.async { print("Coordenadas detectadas después de filtrar: \(filteredCoordinates)") self.parent.scannedCoordinates = filteredCoordinates } } request.recognitionLevel = .accurate let handler = VNImageRequestHandler(cgImage: image, options: [:]) DispatchQueue.global(qos: .userInitiated).async { do { try handler.perform([request]) print("OCR completado y datos procesados.") } catch { print("Error al realizar la solicitud de OCR: \(error.localizedDescription)") } } } private func filterValidCoordinates(from strings: [String]) -> [String: String] { var result: [String: String] = [:] print("Texto antes de filtrar: \(strings)") for string in strings { let trimmedString = string.replacingOccurrences(of: " ", with: "") if parent.useLettersForColumns { let pattern = "^[A-J]\\d{1,2}$" // Letras de A-J seguidas de 1 o 2 dígitos if trimmedString.range(of: pattern, options: .regularExpression) != nil { print("Coordenada válida detectada (letras): \(trimmedString)") result[trimmedString] = "Valor" // Asignación de prueba } } else { let pattern = "^[1-9]\\d{0,1}$" // Solo números, de 1 a 99 if trimmedString.range(of: pattern, options: .regularExpression) != nil { print("Coordenada válida detectada (números): \(trimmedString)") result[trimmedString] = "Valor" } } } print("Coordenadas finales después de filtrar: \(result)") return result } } }
0
0
525
Jan ’25
Unable to Add Font to Asset Catalog as a Font Set (Appearing as "Data")
Hi Support Team, I am new here. I am unable to add my fonts to the asset catalog there is no option to add new font set when I click the plus sign. When I drag my files in they show up as data. I have a Contents.json in the font folder called BeVietnamProFont.font. Is there something I am doing wrong? Thanks SO much! { "info": { "version": 1, "author": "xcode" }, "properties": {}, "fonts": [ { "filename": "BeVietnamPro-Black.ttf", "weight": "black", "style": "normal" }, { "filename": "BeVietnamPro-BlackItalic.ttf", "weight": "black", "style": "italic" }, { "filename": "BeVietnamPro-Bold.ttf", "weight": "bold", "style": "normal" }, { "filename": "BeVietnamPro-BoldItalic.ttf", "weight": "bold", "style": "italic" }, { "filename": "BeVietnamPro-ExtraBold.ttf", "weight": "heavy", "style": "normal" }, { "filename": "BeVietnamPro-ExtraBoldItalic.ttf", "weight": "heavy", "style": "italic" }, { "filename": "BeVietnamPro-ExtraLight.ttf", "weight": "ultralight", "style": "normal" }, { "filename": "BeVietnamPro-ExtraLightItalic.ttf", "weight": "ultralight", "style": "italic" }, { "filename": "BeVietnamPro-Light.ttf", "weight": "light", "style": "normal" }, { "filename": "BeVietnamPro-LightItalic.ttf", "weight": "light", "style": "italic" }, { "filename": "BeVietnamPro-Regular.ttf", "weight": "regular", "style": "normal" }, { "filename": "BeVietnamPro-Italic.ttf", "weight": "regular", "style": "italic" }, { "filename": "BeVietnamPro-Medium.ttf", "weight": "medium", "style": "normal" }, { "filename": "BeVietnamPro-MediumItalic.ttf", "weight": "medium", "style": "italic" }, { "filename": "BeVietnamPro-SemiBold.ttf", "weight": "semibold", "style": "normal" }, { "filename": "BeVietnamPro-SemiBoldItalic.ttf", "weight": "semibold", "style": "italic" }, { "filename": "BeVietnamPro-Thin.ttf", "weight": "thin", "style": "normal" }, { "filename": "BeVietnamPro-ThinItalic.ttf", "weight": "thin", "style": "italic" } ] } ![]("https://developer.apple.com/forums/content/attachment/56835f04-d1c1-468f-808b-9a786562d367" "title=Screenshot 2025-07-13 at 1.05.05 PM.png ;width=539;height=630")
0
0
143
Jul ’25
(tvOS) Categories or Selection Menus Don't Fit the Design
Hi everyone, I'm currently working on my own Apple TV app. So far, things are going pretty well, but right now, I'm stuck on the design of the categories or selection menus. Here's a screenshot of how it looks right now: The green color and the border are intentionally added for now so I can see what is where. My actual goal is to remove the gray bar (or is this the "main bar"?). The pink bar and its border are just design elements that can be removed if needed. I want it to look more "original," like this: Here is the code: let title: String let isSelected: Bool var body: some View { HStack { Text(title) .foregroundColor(isSelected ? .black : .white) .font(.system(size: 22, weight: .regular)) .padding(.leading, 20) Spacer() Image(systemName: "chevron.right") .foregroundColor(isSelected ? .black : .gray) .padding(.trailing, 20) } .frame(height: 50) // Einheitliche Höhe für die Kategorien .background(Color.pink) // Innerer Hintergrund auf pink gesetzt .cornerRadius(10) // Abrundung direkt auf den Hintergrund anwenden .overlay( RoundedRectangle(cornerRadius: 10) .stroke(Color.green, lineWidth: 3) // Äußerer Rahmen auf grün gesetzt ) .padding(.horizontal, 0) // Entferne äußere Ränder .background(Color.clear) // Entferne alle anderen Hintergründe } } struct SettingsView_Previews: PreviewProvider { static var previews: some View { SettingsView() } } I’ve adjusted the code, but it’s still not quite right. When a category is not selected, it appears black instead of gray, like in the original design Here is the code: struct SettingsView: View { @State private var selectedCategory: String? var body: some View { NavigationStack { ZStack { Color.black .edgesIgnoringSafeArea(.all) VStack(spacing: 0) { // Überschrift oben in der Mitte Text("Einstellungen") .font(.system(size: 40, weight: .semibold)) .foregroundColor(.white) .padding(.top, 30) HStack { // Linke Seite mit Logo VStack { Spacer() Image(systemName: "applelogo") .resizable() .scaledToFit() .frame(width: 120, height: 120) .foregroundColor(.white) Spacer() } .frame(width: UIScreen.main.bounds.width * 0.4) // Rechte Seite mit Kategorien VStack(spacing: 15) { ForEach(categories, id: \.self) { category in NavigationLink( value: category, label: { SettingsCategoryView( title: category, isSelected: selectedCategory == category ) } ) .buttonStyle(PlainButtonStyle()) } } .frame(width: UIScreen.main.bounds.width * 0.5) } } } .navigationDestination(for: String.self) { value in Text("\(value)-Ansicht") .font(.title) .foregroundColor(.white) .navigationTitle(value) } } } private var categories: [String] { ["Allgemein", "Benutzer:innen und Accounts", "Video und Audio", "Bildschirmschoner", "AirPlay und HomeKit", "Fernbedienungen und Geräte", "Apps", "Netzwerk", "System", "Entwickler"] } } struct SettingsCategoryView: View { let title: String let isSelected: Bool var body: some View { HStack { Text(title) .foregroundColor(.white) .font(.system(size: 22, weight: .medium)) .padding(.leading, 20) Spacer() Image(systemName: "chevron.right") .foregroundColor(.gray) .padding(.trailing, 20) } .frame(height: 50) // Einheitliche Höhe für die Kategorien .background(isSelected ? Color.gray.opacity(0.3) : Color.clear) // Hervorhebung des ausgewählten Elements .cornerRadius(8) // Abgerundete Ecken .scaleEffect(isSelected ? 1.05 : 1.0) // Fokus-Animation .animation(.easeInOut, value: isSelected) } } struct SettingsView_Previews: PreviewProvider { static var previews: some View { SettingsView() } }
0
0
533
Jan ’25
Multi-Selection List : changing Binding Array to Binding Set and back again
I am trying to create a menu picker for two or three text items. Small miracles, but I have it basically working. Problem is it uses a set, and I want to pass arrays. I need to modify PickerView so the Bound Parameter is an [String] instead of Set. Have been fighting this for a while now... Hoping for insights. struct PickerView: View { @Binding var colorChoices: Set<String> let defaults = UserDefaults.standard var body: some View { let possibleColors = defaults.object(forKey: "ColorChoices") as? [String] ?? [String]() Menu { ForEach(possibleColors, id: \.self) { item in Button(action: { if colorChoices.contains(item) { colorChoices.remove(item) } else { colorChoices.insert(item) } }) { HStack { Text(item) Spacer() if colorChoices.contains(item) { Image(systemName: "checkmark") } } } } } label: { Label("Select Items", systemImage: "ellipsis.circle") } Text("Selected Colors: \(colorChoices, format: .list(type: .and))") } } #Preview("empty") { @Previewable @State var colorChoices: Set<String> = [] PickerView(colorChoices: $colorChoices) } #Preview("Prefilled") { @Previewable @State var colorChoices: Set<String> = ["Red","Blue"] PickerView(colorChoices: $colorChoices) } My Content View is suppose to set default values the first time it runs, if no values already exist... import SwiftUI struct ContentView: View { @State private var viewDidLoad: Bool = false var body: some View { HomeView() .onAppear { // The following code should execute once the first time contentview loads. If a user navigates back to it, it should not execute a second time. if viewDidLoad == false { viewDidLoad = true // load user defaults let defaults = UserDefaults.standard // set the default list of school colors, unless the user has already updated it prior let defaultColorChoices: [String] = ["Black","Gold","Blue","Red","Green","White"] let colorChoices = defaults.object(forKey: "ColorChoices") as? [String] ?? defaultColorChoices defaults.set(colorChoices, forKey: "ColorChoices") } } } } #Preview { ContentView() } PickLoader allows you to dynamically add or delete choices from the list... import SwiftUI struct PickLoader: View { @State private var newColor: String = "" var body: some View { Form { Section("Active Color Choices") { // we should have set a default color list in contentview, so empty string should not be possible. let defaults = UserDefaults.standard let colorChoices = defaults.object(forKey: "ColorChoices") as? [String] ?? [String]() List { ForEach(colorChoices, id: \.self) { color in Text(color) } .onDelete(perform: delete) HStack { TextField("Add a color", text: $newColor) Button("Add"){ defaults.set(colorChoices + [newColor], forKey: "ColorChoices") newColor = "" } } } } } .navigationTitle("Load Picker") Button("Reset Default Choices") { let defaults = UserDefaults.standard //UserDefaults.standard.removeObject(forKey: "ColorChoices") let colorChoices: [String] = ["Black","Gold","Blue","Red","Green","White"] defaults.set(colorChoices, forKey: "ColorChoices") } Button("Clear all choices") { let defaults = UserDefaults.standard defaults.removeObject(forKey: "ColorChoices") } } } func delete(at offsets: IndexSet) { let defaults = UserDefaults.standard var colorChoices = defaults.object(forKey: "ColorChoices") as? [String] ?? [String]() colorChoices.remove(atOffsets: offsets) defaults.set(colorChoices, forKey: "ColorChoices") } #Preview { PickLoader() } And finally HomeView is where I am testing from - to see if binding works properly... import SwiftUI struct HomeView: View { //@State private var selection: Set<String> = [] //@State private var selection: Set<String> = ["Blue"] @State private var selection: Set<String> = ["Blue", "Red"] var body: some View { NavigationStack { List { Section("Edit Picker") { NavigationLink("Load Picker") { PickLoader() } } Section("Test Picker") { PickerView(colorChoices: $selection) } Section("Current Results") { Text("Current Selection: \(selection, format: .list(type: .and))") } } .navigationBarTitle("Hello, World!") } } } #Preview { HomeView() } If anyone uses this code, there are still issues - buttons on Loader don't update the list on the screen for one, and also dealing with deleting choices that are in use - how does picker deal with them? Probably simply add to the list automatically and move on. If anyone has insights on any of this also, great! but first I just need to understand how to accept an array instead of a set in pickerView. I have tried using a computed value with a get and set, but I can't seem to get it right. Thanks for any assistance! Cheers!
2
0
167
Jul ’25
When using the animation, the CPU usage rises to around 20-25%.
I'm new to developing with SwiftUI and I created a Pomodoro app for macOS that runs in the menu bar. I added 4 animations and when the user selects the snow animation, it starts snowing on the screen. But the app uses 20%-30% of the CPU and has high energy consumption. I can't reduce it and I couldn't find a solution. // snow animation import SwiftUI struct SnowflakeView: View { @State private var flakeYPosition: CGFloat = -100 @State private var isAnimating = false private let flakeSize: CGFloat = CGFloat.random(in: 10...30) private let flakeColor: Color = Color( red: Double.random(in: 0.8...1), green: Double.random(in: 0.9...1), blue: Double.random(in: 1...1), opacity: Double.random(in: 0.6...0.8) ) private let animationDuration: Double = Double.random(in: 1...3) private let flakeXPosition: CGFloat = CGFloat.random(in: 0...310) var body: some View { Text("❄️") .font(.system(size: flakeSize)) .foregroundColor(flakeColor) .position(x: flakeXPosition, y: flakeYPosition) .onAppear { if !isAnimating { withAnimation(Animation.linear(duration: animationDuration).repeatForever(autoreverses: false)) { flakeYPosition = 280 + 50 } isAnimating = true } } } } I also have how I run the animation below. ZStack { ForEach(0..<10, id: \.self) { index in if selectedAnimal == "Snow" { SnowflakeView() } else if selectedAnimal == "Rain" { RainDropAnimation() }else if selectedAnimal == "Leaf"{ LeafFallAnimation() }else if selectedAnimal == "Confetti"{ ConfettiAnimation() } } }
0
0
614
Nov ’24
Issue with External Browser on Sign In (Privy SDK limitation)
Hello Apple App Review Team, We are using Privy to enable sign in with Farcaster in our app. Privy is a 3rd party authentication SDK, and it currently opens the authentication URL using the system browser. Unfortunately, this behavior is handled internally by Privy and we do not have access or control to override it in order to present the sign-in flow in-app using SFSafariViewController. We understand the importance of maintaining a seamless and secure user experience, and we fully support the use of SFSafariViewController or ASWebAuthenticationSession. However, since Privy does not expose an option to change this behavior at the moment, we are limited by their current implementation. We have reached out to the Privy team requesting a change or improvement that would allow us to use SFSafariViewController instead of the external browser. In the meantime, we would appreciate your guidance on how to proceed, or whether an exception could be granted due to this 3rd party SDK limitation. Thank you for your understanding and support.
0
0
190
Jul ’25
Optimizing for the 500 widgets and updating it faster in iOS
I am creating 500 textfield widgets and then updating them and all their 40 properties at once. I require to update all 500 widgets with their properties at once as it is a usecase in our app, so pooling and showing only those that will be on screen won't really help in this case. I have found that for updating all these 500 textfield widgets with their 40 properties, the time taken is 80 to 100 milliseconds. However, if I update the non-string properties like .text, then it comes down to half which is 40 to 50 milliseconds. Wanted to know if there was a far more quicker or optimized way to do this? The following snippet of code shows what I am doing: @objc private func handleImmediateMode() { let startTime = CFAbsoluteTimeGetCurrent() for (index, textField) in retainedInputFields.enumerated() { updateAllProperties(for: textField, index: index) } let endTime = CFAbsoluteTimeGetCurrent() print("Immediate Mode -- (500 fields, 40 props): \( (endTime - startTime) * 1000) ms") } In the above code, I have already created the 500 textfield widget, and then in updateAllProperties () function I am passing the textfield widget to it and then updating the 40 properties that the widget has. Particularily, the following properties: textField.placeholder = "Input Field (index)" UILabel().text Seem to be adding the extra 40 - 50 milliseconds.
0
0
28
Jul ’25
Text with standard font style appears smaller on iPadOS than on iOS
I used standard font styles in an iOS app. For example .font(.headline). I hoped that developing this way would allow the adoption of the app to other platforms, relatively easy. However, when trying to run for iPadOS, the text did not increase in size to occupy the more abundant space offered by larger screen, but it actually shrank. Overall, the app does not look great "automatically". Why does it happen? What is the best practice for cross platform development with SwiftUI (with regards to font sizes). I want to make as little as possible human interface design decisions on my own and just let SwiftUI take care of everything. (But I also want the results to look as Apple would consider great looking)
0
0
491
Oct ’24
In-app payment via bottom-up swipe gesture
This question came up, a customer wants to add payment, with gesture, to their app. This gesture is a swipe, from bottom to top (like when minimizing applications). The question immediately arose, will the application pass the review with such UI/UX ? Will there be any problems ? I'm not talking about problems when the user can minimize the application when paying, or pay (accidentally) when minimizing. I want to know if there will be any problems from Apple's rules when releasing the app ? I haven't found the exact information yet
1
0
466
Nov ’24