Create elegant and intuitive apps that integrate seamlessly with Apple platforms.

All subtopics
Posts under Design topic

Post

Replies

Boosts

Views

Activity

Need Help with Guideline 4.2 - Minimum Functionality
I recently got feedback for my app under Guideline 4.2 - Design - Minimum Functionality, and I’m a bit confused. Apple mentioned that the app isn’t “app-like” enough and doesn’t provide sufficient entertainment value or utility. However, I genuinely think my app is unique compared to others on the market. Most similar apps only offer basic features like scorekeeping and saving the game. My app goes beyond that by tracking detailed statistics based on the types of scores achieved during the game. At the end, there’s even a Player Ratings section, which enhances competition and makes the experience more fun for players. Additionally, in today’s gaming scene, many groups play the traditional 101 game with a reward and penalty system. My app uniquely incorporates a reward system, something no other app in the market currently offers. I believe my app has the potential to stand out and meet the needs of a wide audience. Has anyone faced similar feedback? Or does anyone have suggestions on how I could better address this issue? Thanks in advance! 😊
0
0
533
Dec ’24
SwiftData and #DEBUG with the canvas...
Hi all, Very new to this. Just getting into swift data, and am frustrated with the canvas not working with modelContainers in SwiftData. My understanding is that they work if inMemory = true, but not in the default case where data is persistent after an app is quit. Can anyone tell me if it is possible to conditionally create the modelContainer type based on a flag... If Bool:Canvas then inMemory = True, Else False... Then using this flag for all data models so my list views populate on the canvas, without having to run the simulator each time... I would assume you could also pre-populate the inMemory option if it is empty also... Or is there a simple and obvious solution that I am oblivious to. If it is possible, is it worth the time, hassle, and any possible issues?
0
0
532
Dec ’24
drop-down box Bug
There is a display issue when browsing wireless networks in the dropdown menu. In iOS version 18.1.1, the Wi-Fi switch is in the closed state; Step 1: Open the notification dropdown, and the first image bug appears; It will take some time for it to display [normally.]
1
0
511
Dec ’24
Apple Air Pods Upgrade!
Good evening. I have come up with this amazing and revolutionary idea that is going to change the ent world for the better. I’m a 23 year old Design Engineer from Greece and I would like to come to direct contact with the Apple Design Team, in order to discuss this project and the best case scenario, sell it to you. The foldable iPhone is not a good idea. Its not revolutionary and it’s going to leave a big black mark in Apple history. With my idea, the whole world will see again the greatness of the biggest company in history.
2
0
516
Dec ’24
SwiftUI: How to create different background colors for List sections?
I'm trying to achieve a specific UI design in SwiftUI where the bottom section of my List has a different background color than the top section. For example in the Medications portion of the Health app, the "Your Medications" Section has a different background than the top "Log" Section. How do I achieve this?: Here some example code. I wonder if I am supposed to use two Lists instead. If I use two Lists though and nest it in a ScrollView, the height of the lists needs to be specified. I am working with dynamic content, though so I don't think that is ideal. class ProtocolMedication {} // Example model struct HomeView: View { @Query private var protocolMedications: [ProtocolMedication] var body: some View { NavigationStack { List { // Upper sections with default background Section { Text("Content 1") } header: { Text("Log") } // Bottom section that needs different background Section { ForEach(protocolMedications) { medication in Text(medication.name) } } header: { Text("Your Medications") } } .listStyle(.insetGrouped) } } }
1
0
665
Dec ’24
Some colors are missing during first app launch
Recently I decided to download my app from the App Store and found out that during the first launch some colors were missing or displayed incorreclty. For example one button was blue, although switching dark mode on and off solved button color it. Some colors were completely missing and the tab bar buttons were blue as well. Any advices? I'm using iOS 18.2 and XCode 16.1
1
0
339
Dec ’24
SwiftUI FileDocument: Modify the default save dialog
Is it possible to change the default save dialog that appears when creating a document based MacOS app in SwiftUI? I have a basic FileDocument struct that gets called to a view using a DocumentGroup scene. struct MyFile: FileDocument { static let readableContentTypes: [UTType] = [.myFileType] static let writeableContentTypes: [UTType] = [.myFileType] var list: [String] init(configuration: ReadConfiguration) throws { let data = configuration.file.regularFileContents! let JSONDecoder = JSONDecoder() do { try list = JSONDecoder.decode([String].self, from: data) } catch { throw CocoaError(.fileReadCorruptFile) } } func fileWrapper(configuration: WriteConfiguration) throws -> FileWrapper { let JSONEncoder = JSONEncoder() JSONEncoder.outputFormatting = .prettyPrinted do { data = try JSONEncoder.encode(self.list) } catch { print(error.localizedDescription) throw CocoaError(.fileWriteUnknown) } return .init(regularFileWithContents: data) } } This gets called at the DocumentGroup DocumentGroup(newDocument: MyFile(), editor: { document in ContentView(document: document.$document) }) But when I save the file, I want the save dialog that appears to have something like a 'Tags' textField that can also store information about the file. Something similar to this: (https://i.sstatic.net/AJQ3YNb8.png) From what I can find, there isn't much information about this other than manually creating an NSSavePanel class and overriding the current save function
1
0
438
Mar ’25
Seeking Developer Insights Regarding 4.3(b) Review Response
We recently received feedback under Guideline 4.3(b) suggesting our app duplicates functionality found in other apps in this category. However, our app is fundamentally not a dating app. It is a conversation facilitator designed to foster meaningful connections for friendships, networking, and shared interests. While romantic connections may occur naturally, they are not the primary focus. Thus, we are seeking insights on this key question: How do developers effectively demonstrate feature differentiation to reviewers? We want to clearly show how our app’s functionality uniquely addresses user needs and provides value beyond existing solutions. Our Core Features: Our app introduces distinct features that differentiate it from traditional apps in this space: Paths: Psychology-based prompts embedded in chats encourage users to explore meaningful topics like values and aspirations. These prompts are dynamically triggered to keep conversations engaging and productive. Aura: A rewards system that incentivizes thoughtful, high-quality engagement by awarding points for meaningful conversations, which can unlock additional features. Spark Matches: Real-time, themed events pair users for structured, 15-minute conversations on topics like technology or travel. Curated prompts ensure the focus is on shared interests, not romance. Flame Matches: AI-personalized matches adapt to user conversations, connecting individuals based on compatibility. Chats begin anonymously, focusing on personalities rather than appearances, and are designed for platonic, professional, or friendship connections. Market Analysis: Our app addresses key gaps in the connection space: No apps embed conversation prompts directly into chats; nor do they trigger them regularly or dynamically, to foster deeper discussions over a sustained period. No apps have rewards systems designed to specifically incentivize meaningful engagement. No apps have matchmaking systems that adapt dynamically based on users’ past conversations. No apps support the combination of real-time, one-on-one themed conversations with curated prompts. Traction: As an incorporated business with over a year of experience, we have helped thousands of users build platonic, professional, and interest-based connections. For example, users in relationships join our events to find new friends, and professionals use Spark Matches to discuss shared interests like technology. Consistent feedback highlights our prompts and structured events as refreshing alternatives to superficial, appearance-driven platforms. Our rapidly growing user base has validated the demand for these features, and we would like to bring this experience natively to them via a mobile app on the App Store. Additional Context: While some basic chat functionality may overlap with existing platforms, our focus is on facilitating meaningful conversations and incentivizing a thoughtful conversation culture that represents a novel approach validated by user research and feedback. We welcome advice from developers who have successfully highlighted their app’s uniqueness when facing similar review challenges. Thank you in advance! :)
2
0
514
Jan ’25
Guideline 4.3(a) - Design - Spam - automatic rejection
I previously written here, and some advices were to appeal to rejection sending them message describing uniqueness of the app. Nothing is working. In short, i have a vpn app (of course by design shares some concept with other apps that are in the app store). But since the rejection i have completely changed the ui, added built in browser, p2p messenger so users could interact with each other without any interference. The app is completely free with no ads. I thought this is it, there's no way it would reject this time, but... i get a notification with rejection repeating the same old message. I'm extremely frustrated and don't know what to do. Tried changing the logo of the app, the name to "Incognito - Messenger, VPN", app store screenshots. I've already appealed with screenshots describing unique features that other vpn apps don't have, but the message just repeats from app review team. Submission ID: 1a49ee0b-c4e2-4a36-8372-e4d3b9a8b13f Does anybody have an advice what i can do?
3
0
2.0k
Jan ’25
UITabBarController y psoition issue for iOS 18
I am trying to give bottom padding to tabbar i.e ** tabBarFrame.origin.y = view.frame.height - tabBarHeight - 30** but it is not moving up from bottom, it gets sticked to bottom = 0 and the tabbar content moving up taher than tabbar itself.. Code snippet is - `i override func viewDidLayoutSubviews() { super.viewDidLayoutSubviews() let tabBarHeight: CGFloat = 70 // Custom height for the capsule tab bar var tabBarFrame = tabBar.frame tabBarFrame.size.height = tabBarHeight tabBarFrame.size.width = view.frame.width - 40 tabBarFrame.origin.y = view.frame.height - tabBarHeight - 30 tabBarFrame.origin.x = 20 tabBar.frame = tabBarFrame tabBar.layer.cornerRadius = tabBarHeight / 2 tabBar.clipsToBounds = true view.bringSubviewToFront(tabBar) }` Can anyone please help to resolve the issue for iOS 18, it is coming in iOS 18 rest previous versions are fine with the code.
0
0
317
Jan ’25
Open UIViewController when QR Code is scanned
Hi developers, I have a question if it is possible to open in my application not main window but a specific ViewController, when application is installed but not running. When the application is running in background and I scan QR code, then specific ViewController is opened over SceneDelegate and method 'userActivity'. But this does not work when the application is only installed, but not running. The Appstore link is here: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/don%C3%A1tor/id6473955033
3
0
881
Feb ’25
How do you make buttons inline with each other?
I want to make my buttons inline with each other, but spaced apart, a bit like the apple topbar BUT in swift. My code: struct NormalPageView: View { var body: some View { VStack { NavigationView { Form { Section { Image(systemName: "house.fill") Spacer() Image(systemName: "plus") Spacer() Image(systemName: "gearshape.fill") } } }
1
0
337
Jan ’25
Apple keeps preventing us for updating our app
It has been over a month since we first attempted to update our app. The issue we wanted to resolve is a bug that prevents in-app purchases from functioning properly. Fixing this bug was crucial—not only for our users but also for us as a company. However, what seemed like a simple fix has turned into an absolute nightmare. Despite our app successfully undergoing 20+ updates in the past, we now face a consistent rejection under guideline 4.3(a) - Design - Spam. Every single submission has been met with the same response. We’ve made significant changes to the app, introduced numerous features, and thoroughly reviewed every aspect, yet the rejections persist. Desperate for clarity, we scheduled a call with an Apple representative. During the call, we were told that the issue was related to our app’s screenshots. We accepted their feedback, updated the screenshots, and resubmitted the app—only to be rejected again. Since then, we’ve submitted the app three additional times, each with new sets of screenshots. Yet, the outcome has remained unchanged. Every review has been completed within about 20 minutes, with the same generic response: "Hello, The issues we previously identified still need your attention. If you have any questions, we are here to help. Reply to this message in App Store Connect and let us know." We’ve now updated the screenshots three times, but nothing has changed. Is the issue truly related to the screenshots? Or is there something else at play? We’ve already spent over 30 days trying to resolve this. Should we continue uploading a 4th, 5th, or even 6th set of screenshots, only to receive the same rejection? The lack of clarity is incredibly disheartening. I’ve pleaded with Apple to provide specific, actionable feedback so we can address the problem effectively, but the responses are always the same—copy-pasted and vague. I’m feeling completely devastated and frustrated. At this point, I’m even considering giving up on my job entirely. If anyone has advice or insights, please help. I don’t know what to do anymore.
3
0
390
Jan ’25
how to save the state when I open another APP ?
how to save the state of my APP when I open another APP so that It can restore when I re-open it? my app will use over 10mb memory so if I open another APP(my app will go background) it will closed at all. when I re-open it it will restart. but I do not want it I want if I open Page A and then it go background and when I re-open it it still is Page A and do not restart.
2
0
360
Feb ’25
learning coregraphics help: connecting line to circles
Hi everyone, im in the process of delving more into coregraphics with swiftui, but I am at a roadblock. First I would like to ask, what are some good resources to learn coregraphics? Secondly: I currently have a circle view made and what I want to do is to make my circle view modular so that it can be directly connected to another given circle by a line. How can I do this? For example, I want my circles to represent nodes and be able to connect by lines to other nodes that are related. Thanks in advanced. Here is my code for the circle view: @State private var circleProgress: CGFloat = 0 let timer = Timer.publish(every: 0.016, on: .main, in: .common).autoconnect() private let animationDuration: TimeInterval = 1.5 @Binding var startPoint: CGPoint @Binding var endPoint: CGPoint var body: some View { GeometryReader { geometry in Canvas { context, size in // Circle parameters let circleSize: CGFloat = 50 let circleOrigin = CGPoint( x: size.width / 4, y: size.height / 2 - circleSize / 2 ) let circleRect = CGRect( origin: circleOrigin, size: CGSize(width: circleSize, height: circleSize) ) let circleCenter = CGPoint( x: circleOrigin.x + circleSize / 2, y: circleOrigin.y + circleSize / 2 ) // Animate circle creation var circlePath = Path() circlePath.addArc( center: circleCenter, radius: circleSize / 2, startAngle: .degrees(0), endAngle: .degrees(360 * circleProgress), clockwise: false ) context.addFilter(.shadow(color: .white.opacity(0.6), radius: 5, x: 1, y: 1)) // Add white shadow context.stroke( circlePath, with: .linearGradient( Gradient(colors: [.purple, .white]), startPoint: circleRect.origin, endPoint: CGPoint(x: circleRect.maxX, y: circleRect.maxY) ), lineWidth: 5 ) } .frame(width: 300, height: 150) .onReceive(timer) { _ in // Update circle progress let progressChange = 0.02 / animationDuration if circleProgress < 1.0 { circleProgress = min(circleProgress + progressChange, 1.0) } else { circleProgress = 0.0 // Reset the circle to repeat the animation } // Get the starting and ending points of the Canvas view startPoint = CGPoint(x: geometry.frame(in: .global).minX, y: geometry.frame(in: .global).minY) endPoint = CGPoint(x: geometry.frame(in: .global).maxX, y: geometry.frame(in: .global).maxY) // Print the points for debugging print("Start Point: \(startPoint.x), \(startPoint.y)") print("End Point: \(endPoint.x), \(endPoint.y)") } } .frame(width: 300, height: 150) } }
1
0
534
Jan ’25